Calculator overview
Inputs and outputs
This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.
Inputs
- Members (row b is member b, from its start joint to its end joint; leave a row blank when the member is not used) (required)
-
Default 3 rows
About this input
Up to 15 members: row b is member b from its start joint to its end joint (joint numbers 1 to 8, two different joints in use). Every member has the same section. Leave a row blank when the member is not used.
Column Range or allowed values Start joint 1 to 8 End joint 1 to 8 - Your prediction (challenge 1) (required)
-
Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Member 1, Member 2, Member 3, Member 4, Member 5, Member 6, Member 7, Member 8, Member 9, Member 10, Member 11, Member 12, Member 13
About this input
Your prediction for challenge 1: Not yet predicted, or Member 1 to Member 13 (the members of challenge 1's Pratt truss), the member you expect to carry the largest compression. The forces of challenge 1 stay hidden until you predict. Not used outside challenge 1.
- Second moment of area I (required)
-
Unit cm^4 Default 100 Range 0.01 to 100000
About this input
The second moment of area I of every member, 0.01 to 100,000 cm^4. It sets the Euler buckling load of each compression member.
- Scan to (required)
-
Unit m Default 3.5 Range 0 to 20
About this input
The highest position of the design coordinate in the scan, 0 to 20 m, above the lowest.
- Target member (required)
-
Default 1 Range 1 to 15
About this input
The member whose force the inverse matches to the target: a member in use, 1 to 15.
- Target force (required)
-
Unit kN Default 12 Range -100000 to 100000
About this input
The force the target member should carry, kN, tension positive, -100,000 to 100,000.
- Scan from (required)
-
Unit m Default 0.5 Range 0 to 20
About this input
The lowest position of the design coordinate in the scan, 0 to 20 m.
- Member area A (required)
-
Unit mm^2 Default 1000 Range 10 to 100000
About this input
The cross-section area A of every member, 10 to 100,000 mm^2. It scales the displacements only.
- Challenge number (required)
-
Default 0 Range 0 to 5
About this input
Selects a challenge: 0 for none, 1 to 5 for a predefined challenge scored on the truss as entered.
- Allowable tension (required)
-
Unit kN Default 150 Range 0.1 to 100000
About this input
The tension force a member may carry, 0.1 to 100,000 kN (your number; no design code).
- Allowable compression (required)
-
Unit kN Default 100 Range 0.1 to 100000
About this input
The compression force a member may carry, 0.1 to 100,000 kN, checked beside the Euler buckling load.
- Design axis (required)
-
Default Vertical (y) Allowed Vertical (y), Horizontal (x)
About this input
The coordinate of the design joint that the scan moves: Vertical (y) or Horizontal (x).
- Joints (row k is joint k: its position, its support and its load; leave a row blank when the joint is not used) (required)
-
Default 3 rows
About this input
Up to 8 joints: row k is joint k with its x and y in m (0 to 20), its support (Free, Pin, Roller (vertical reaction) or Roller (horizontal reaction)) and its load components in kN (-1,000 to 1,000, positive along +x and +y). A row in use needs x, y and a support; a blank load reads 0. Leave a row blank when the joint is not used. Joints must be at least 0.05 m apart.
Column Range or allowed values x (m) 0 to 20 y (m) 0 to 20 Support Free, Pin, Roller (vertical reaction), Roller (horizontal reaction) Load x (kN) -1000 to 1000 Load y (kN) -1000 to 1000 - Elastic modulus E (required)
-
Unit GPa Default 200 Range 1 to 400
About this input
The elastic modulus E of every member, 1 to 400 GPa (200 is about steel). It scales the displacements and the buckling loads, never the forces.
- Design joint (required)
-
Default 3 Range 1 to 8
About this input
The joint whose coordinate the design scan moves: a joint in use, 1 to 8.
Outputs
- Target member force at the refined position
-
Unit kN
About this output
The target member force at the refined position, kN. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Refined force less the target
-
Unit kN
About this output
The refined force less the target force, kN. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Refined position
-
Unit m
About this output
The position of the design coordinate that meets the target: the hit, the refinement step that met it, or the closest point found; blank when no position reaches the target. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Target member force there
-
Unit kN
About this output
The target member force at the closest scan position, kN. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- The refinement inside the first bracket: each Illinois step, its position, force, gap to the target and bracket
-
No unit declared
About this output
The refinement inside the first bracket: up to 4 Illinois steps, each with its position, the target member force, the gap to the target and the bracket it used. A step not run is a blank row; a step that met an unstable position shows no force; the whole grid is blank without a bracket.
- Model Status
-
No unit declared
About this output
NOT VALID with the reason when an input cannot be used or the truss is a mechanism (too few reactions, too few members, or unstable); CHECK when the results are shown but the truss is close to a mechanism, no load is applied, or a member is over its allowable force or buckles; otherwise OK.
- The members: joints, length, force (tension positive), type, checks, the share of the largest force and the sensitivity to the design coordinate
-
No unit declared
About this output
The members: 15 rows, member b with its start and end joints, length (m), force (kN, tension positive), type (Tension, Compression or Zero force), utilisation, Euler buckling load (kN), buckling ratio, width share (the force over the largest force, for drawing) and sensitivity (kN per m of the design coordinate). A member not in use is a blank row; the force, type, ratios, share and sensitivity are blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction; the whole grid is blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Model version
-
No unit declared
About this output
The model version.
- Members over the allowable or buckling
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of members whose governing ratio is above 1. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Formula module versions
-
No unit declared
About this output
The formula modules the model is built from, with their versions.
- Bracket to
-
Unit m
About this output
The upper end of that bracket, m; blank without a bracket. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Support reactions
-
No unit declared
About this output
The reactions the supports give: 2 per Pin and 1 per roller. Blank when an input check fails.
- Bracket from
-
Unit m
About this output
The lower end of the first bracket in which the target member force crosses the target, m; blank without a bracket. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Zero-force members
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of members whose force reads 0 (within 1E-9 of the largest force). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Target member force per metre of the design coordinate
-
Unit kN/m
About this output
The rate of change of the target member force as the design coordinate moves, kN per m, at the entered geometry (the exact derivative). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- The design scan: one frame per position of the design coordinate, its stability and every member force
-
No unit declared
About this output
The design scan: 21 frames, k = 0 to 20, each with its position, 1 when stable, the stability index, the design joint's x and y, the largest tension, the largest compression, the target member force and every member force (kN). An unstable frame shows its position only; the forces are blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction; the whole grid is blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Closest scan position
-
Unit m
About this output
The scan position closest to the target: the hit, the closer end of the bracket, or the closest stable frame; blank when every position is unstable. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Scan step
-
Unit m
About this output
The step between scan positions, m: the stated accuracy of a scan answer. Blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Stability index
-
No unit declared
About this output
The stability index: the largest free stiffness diagonal times the sum of the absolute entries of the inverse, a pure number about 7 to 1,000 for ordinary trusses; above 100,000 close to a mechanism, above 1E10 unstable. Blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Stable scan positions
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of scan positions at which the truss is stable. Blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Deformed-shape scale
-
No unit declared
About this output
The factor by which the drawn deformed shape exaggerates the displacements, so that the largest is 8% of the truss size. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Challenge result
-
No unit declared
About this output
No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.
- Members + reactions - 2 x joints
-
No unit declared
About this output
Members + reactions - 2 x joints: negative is a mechanism by count, 0 statically determinate (if stable), positive the number of redundant members or reactions. Blank when an input check fails.
- Inverse result
-
No unit declared
About this output
The outcome of the inverse: the target met at a scan position, met by refinement inside the first bracket, or a CHECK text (not met within 4 steps, an unstable refinement step, no scan position reaches the target, or every position unstable). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Equilibrium residual
-
No unit declared
About this output
The largest unbalanced force at a free joint direction over the largest load: the check that the solve balances (about 1E-16). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Challenge feedback
-
No unit declared
About this output
Feedback on the selected challenge: the prediction prompt, the integrity text, the met text or the not-met hint (blank with none).
- Members that buckle
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of members whose compression is above the Euler buckling load. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Challenge goal
-
No unit declared
About this output
The goal of the selected challenge (blank with none).
- Challenge score
-
No unit declared
About this output
The challenge score: 100 when met, else 0.
- Challenge: the value scored
-
No unit declared
About this output
The value the selected challenge scores: the member with the largest compression (1), the tie force in kN (2), the total member length in m (3), the force in member 5 in kN (4) or the largest governing ratio (5); blank when not valid, awaiting a prediction or when the integrity rule fails.
- Member with the largest tension
-
No unit declared
About this output
The first member carrying the largest tension (within the 1E-9 tie band); blank when no member is in tension. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Largest tension
-
Unit kN
About this output
The largest tension force, kN (0 when no member is in tension). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Largest governing ratio
-
No unit declared
About this output
The largest governing ratio over the members: the larger of the utilisation (force over the allowable force) and the buckling ratio (compression over the Euler load). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Members in use
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of member rows in use.
- Total member length
-
Unit m
About this output
The total length of the members, m. Blank when the inputs are not valid.
- The joints: position, support, displacement, reactions and the exaggerated deformed position
-
No unit declared
About this output
The joints: 8 rows, joint k with its x and y (m), support, displacement u and v (mm), reactions in x and y (kN, blank on a free direction) and the exaggerated deformed position (m). A joint not in use is a blank row; the displacements, reactions and deformed positions are blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction; the whole grid is blank when the inputs are not valid.
- Joints in use
-
No unit declared
About this output
The number of joint rows in use.
- Largest compression
-
Unit kN
About this output
The largest compression force, kN, as a positive size (0 when no member is in compression). Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Largest joint displacement
-
Unit mm
About this output
The largest joint displacement, mm. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
- Member with the largest compression
-
No unit declared
About this output
The first member carrying the largest compression (within the 1E-9 tie band); blank when no member is in compression. Blank when the inputs are not valid or while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.
LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.
Methodology
Purpose and model boundary
This lab solves a plane pin-jointed truss of up to 8 joints and 15 members and then works backwards from a force you want. Every member is a straight two-force member with the same section (one elastic modulus, area and second moment of area), loads act at the joints only, and each joint is free, pinned, or on a roller. For the truss you draw, the model returns every member force with its type, utilisation and Euler buckling ratio, every joint displacement and reaction, an exaggerated deformed shape, and the sensitivity of every member force to one chosen joint coordinate. It then moves that coordinate through 21 positions (the design scan) and finds the position at which a chosen member carries a target force (the inverse). Five scored challenges use the same model.
It is a lab for learning how member forces follow the geometry of a truss: why a shallow truss carries large forces, which members carry nothing, how a statically indeterminate truss shares load by stiffness, and how a design coordinate can be tuned to meet a force. It is not a design tool. The allowable forces are your own numbers, the buckling load is the ideal pin-ended Euler load with no imperfection or code factor, the joints are perfect pins and the members carry no weight. Do not use it to size or check a real structure.
The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what it returns: the members coloured and sized by their force, the supports and loads, the deformed shape, the scan film and the force-against-position chart. The page computes no force, displacement, reaction or position itself.
Inputs and units
Lengths and coordinates are in metres (m) and forces in kilonewtons (kN), tension positive. A load is positive along +x (right) or +y (up).
| Input | Meaning and unit |
|---|---|
| Joints | Up to 8 rows. Row k is joint k: its x and y, each from 0 to 20 m; its support, Free, Pin, Roller (vertical reaction) or Roller (horizontal reaction); and its load components, each from -1,000 to 1,000 kN (a blank load reads 0). Joints must be at least 0.05 m apart. A row left blank is no joint; at least two joints are needed. |
| Members | Up to 15 rows. Row b is member b, from its start joint to its end joint (whole numbers 1 to 8, two different joints in use). Two members may not join the same two joints. A row left blank is no member; at least one is needed, and every joint must touch a member. |
| Elastic modulus E | From 1 to 400 GPa (default 200, about steel). It scales the displacements and the buckling loads, never the forces. |
| Member area A | From 10 to 100,000 mm² (default 1,000). It scales the displacements only. |
| Second moment of area I | From 0.01 to 100,000 cm⁴ (default 100). It sets each member's Euler buckling load. |
| Allowable tension | From 0.1 to 100,000 kN (default 150): the tension a member may carry. |
| Allowable compression | From 0.1 to 100,000 kN (default 100): the compression a member may carry, checked beside its buckling load. |
| Design joint | A joint in use, 1 to 8 (default 3): the joint whose coordinate the scan moves. |
| Design axis | Vertical (y) (default) or Horizontal (x): which coordinate of the design joint the scan moves. |
| Scan from, Scan to | Each from 0 to 20 m, with Scan from below Scan to (defaults 0.5 and 3.5 m): the range of the design coordinate. |
| Target member | A member in use, 1 to 15 (default 1): the member whose force the inverse matches. |
| Target force | From -100,000 to 100,000 kN (default 12): the force the target member should carry, tension positive. |
| Challenge number | 0 for free exploration, or 1 to 5 to load a challenge. |
| Your prediction | Not yet predicted, or Member 1 to Member 13: in challenge 1, the member you expect to carry the largest compression. |
A Pin holds a joint in x and y, a Roller (vertical reaction) holds it in y only, and a Roller (horizontal reaction) in x only.
Where each input is set:
- On the canvas only: the joints and their supports and loads, the members, the design joint and axis, the scan range, the target member and your prediction in challenge 1. Tap an empty spot to add a joint; tap a joint for its support, its load, a new member and the design choice; tap a member to make it the target or remove it.
- Draggable on the canvas: every joint, and at Experiment the two ends of the scan range along the design axis.
- In the input panel: the elastic modulus, area, second moment of area, the two allowable forces, the target force and the challenge number.
Governing relationships
The direct stiffness method. For member b from joint s to joint e, with dx and dy the differences of their coordinates and L = √(dx² + dy²), the direction cosines are c = dx/L and s = dy/L. Its stiffness in the plane is (E A / L) times the 2 x 2 block [c², cs; cs, s²], added into the rows and columns of its two joints. Because every member has the same E A, the model assembles the matrix without E A (normalised), with blocks (1/L)[c², cs; cs, s²]. Each joint has two degrees of freedom, x and y, so the system is 16 x 16. A restrained or unused degree of freedom becomes an identity row and column (the zero-one method), so the size never changes. Solving K d̂ = F, with F the loads on the free degrees of freedom, gives the normalised displacements d̂; the real displacements are d̂ / (E A).
Member force. With du and dv the differences of d̂ between the member's end and start,
N = (dx·du + dy·dv) / L² (kN, tension positive).
E and A cancel, so the forces never depend on E, A or I, even in a statically indeterminate truss.
Counting supports and members (Maxwell's rule). With r the reactions (2 for a pin, 1 for a roller), m the members and j the joints in use, a plane truss needs r ≥ 3, and the determinacy degree is m + r - 2j. Below 0 the truss is a mechanism by count; 0 is statically determinate if stable; above 0 is the number of redundant members or reactions. The count is necessary but not sufficient: three joints in a line, or supports that all push the same way, leave a truss unstable even when the count is met.
The stability index. The model decides stability by a pure number, φ = sK x (sum of the sizes of every entry of K⁻¹ over the free degrees of freedom), where sK is the largest free diagonal of K. φ does not change when the whole truss is scaled. An ordinary truss reads about 7 to 1,000; φ grows as (span / rise)² as a truss flattens. A truss is unstable when φ is above 10¹⁰ (or K cannot be inverted), and close to a mechanism when φ is above 100,000. In exact arithmetic a mechanism makes K singular; in floating point its φ comes out far above 10¹⁰, so the decision does not depend on rounding.
Zero band. A force within 1×10⁻⁹ of the largest force reads 0, and the member is a zero-force member. A reaction within 1×10⁻⁹ of the larger of the largest force and the largest load reads 0.
Member checks. For each member,
- utilisation = N / allowable tension in tension, and -N / allowable compression in compression;
- Euler buckling load Pcr = π² E I / L² (pin-ended), with E I in kN m²;
- buckling ratio = -N / Pcr in compression, else 0;
- the member is over when the larger of the two ratios exceeds 1, and buckles when its buckling ratio exceeds 1 (each with a band of 1×10⁻⁹).
Reactions and equilibrium. At each joint the member forces, the applied load and any reaction balance. On a restrained axis the unbalance of the member forces and the load is the reaction; on a free axis it is about 0, and the largest such unbalance divided by the largest load is the equilibrium residual.
Deformed shape. Each joint is drawn at its position plus its displacement times a scale chosen so the largest displacement is drawn as 8% of the truss's size.
Sensitivity. Differentiating K d̂ = F with respect to the design coordinate ξ, with the loads fixed, gives K (dd̂/dξ) = -(dK/dξ) d̂. The model solves this with the same K and then differentiates N = (dx·du + dy·dv) / L² directly, giving dN/dξ for every member in kN/m. It is exact to rounding and uses no finite-difference step.
The design scan. Position k, for k = 0 to 20, is ξ = Scan from + (Scan to - Scan from) x k / 20, with the last position exactly Scan to. Each position is a full solve with the design joint moved there. The scan resolution is (Scan to - Scan from) / 20.
The target test. At a stable position the gap is g = N(target member) - target force. The target is met when |g| ≤ 1×10⁻⁵ x max(1, |target force|).
The inverse: first event, then Illinois refinement. In scan order, the first event wins: a hit (a stable position that meets the target), or a bracket (two neighbouring stable positions where g changes sign). A hit at a position comes before a bracket starting there, and a sign change across an unstable position is not a bracket. Inside a bracket [a, b] the model takes 4 steps of the Illinois method, a modified regula falsi: the next point is c = b - g(b)·(b - a) / (g(b) - g(a)), kept inside the bracket; c replaces the end with the same sign of g, and when the same end is kept twice its g is halved, which stops the method from stalling on one end. The refinement stops when a step meets the target, or when a step lands on an unstable position.
Calculation sequence
- Check the inputs in the order of the status list under Errors and warnings. A blank support reads Free and a blank load 0.
- Count the reactions and the determinacy degree, and number the degrees of freedom.
- Assemble the normalised stiffness matrix of the truss as entered, find its stability index, and solve for the displacements and member forces.
- Derive the member checks, the reactions, the equilibrium residual, the displacements in millimetres and the deformed shape.
- Find the sensitivity of every member force to the design coordinate.
- Solve the truss at each of the 21 scan positions and find the first hit or bracket.
- Refine inside the bracket by up to 4 Illinois steps.
- Set the status and, in a challenge, check the challenge's fixed values and score it.
Outputs and interpretation
- Inverse result: TARGET MET at a scan position, TARGET MET by refinement inside the bracket, or one of the CHECK texts listed under Errors and warnings.
- Joints and members in use, support reactions (r) and the determinacy degree m + r - 2j.
- Stability index: φ above; larger means closer to a mechanism.
- Largest tension and largest compression (kN, the compression as a positive size), each with the first member that carries it.
- Largest utilisation, and the numbers of members over, that buckle, and of zero-force members.
- Largest displacement (mm), the deformation scale of the drawing, and the equilibrium residual (a pure number, about 1×10⁻¹⁴ for a solved truss).
- Total member length (m).
- Scan resolution (m), the number of stable scan positions, the closest scan position and its force, the bracket ends, the refined position (m) with its force and its gap to the target (kN), and the sensitivity of the target member (kN/m).
- Member table: length, force, type (Tension, Compression or Zero force), utilisation, buckling load, buckling ratio, width share (the force over the largest force, which sets the drawn width) and sensitivity.
- Joint table: position, support, displacements u and v (mm), reactions on restrained axes (kN) and deformed position.
- Scan frames: for each of the 21 positions, whether it is stable, its stability index, the design joint's position, the largest tension and compression, the target member's force and every member's force.
- Refinement steps: each Illinois step's position, target member force, gap and bracket.
Reading the canvas: members in tension are blue, in compression red, and zero-force members grey; a wider member carries more force, and a member that is over is outlined. The deformed shape is exaggerated by the deformation scale. The scan film plays the 21 positions, and the chart plots the largest tension, the largest compression and the target member's force against the position. An unstable frame shows its position and no forces.
Challenges
A challenge loads its own truss; nothing is replaced, so your truss is scored as entered. Each challenge fixes its joints, members and loads (and in challenges 3 and 5 the material) except the coordinates named in its goal, and the model checks every fixed value; if one is changed, the challenge reads NOT MET with a hint to reload it. The design, scan and target inputs are always yours. The model scores each challenge MET (100) or NOT MET (0).
- Which member is most compressed? Predict the member that carries the largest compression in this bridge truss, then reveal the forces. It is met when the member you name is in compression and carries the largest compression (within the tie band).
- Set the tie force. Raise or lower the apex so that the bottom tie carries 10 kN (within 0.1 kN). The value scored is member 1's force.
- The lightest safe apex. Find an apex height at which no member is over its allowable force or buckles, using at most 12.75 m of members in total. The value scored is the total member length; it is met when no member is over and the total is at most 12.75 m.
- Make a zero-force member. Move joint 4 so that member 5 (joint 3 to joint 4) carries no force (within 0.2 kN). The value scored is member 5's force.
- Reshape the Warren truss. Move the two top joints so that no member is over its allowable force or buckles. The value scored is the largest utilisation; it is met when no member is over.
Challenge 1 holds back the answer until you predict: while your prediction reads Not yet predicted, the inverse result, the forces, the member checks, the displacements, the reactions, the scan forces and the refinement are blank, and the challenge reads NOT MET with a prompt to predict. The geometry, the counts, the stability index, the scan positions and their stability stay shown.
What to take from the lab: the forces depend on the geometry and the loads, not on the material; a flatter truss carries larger forces (in a king-post truss the tie carries load x span / (4 x height)); counting members and reactions is necessary but not sufficient for stability; and an inverse answer is only as good as the scan that brackets it.
Validation and status logic
The status reads the first match in the list under Errors and warnings. Items 1 to 11 are checked on the values you entered, in a challenge too; items 12 to 14 on the truss as used, once items 1 to 11 pass. The CHECK items come next, and every result is shown under them; then OK. The inverse result has its own CHECK texts, which do not change the status.
Assumptions and limitations
- Plane, pin-jointed truss; loads at the joints only; no self-weight, member loads, settlement or temperature.
- Every member has the same section and material. Small displacements: the forces are found on the undeformed geometry.
- Supports are pins and level or vertical rollers only; no inclined rollers or rigid joints.
- Buckling is the ideal pin-ended Euler load, with no imperfection, eccentricity or code factor.
- The scan moves one coordinate of one joint through 21 positions, and only the first bracket is refined, by 4 steps. A force that jumps through an unstable position between two scan positions can form a false bracket; the inverse then ends unmet.
- Every test has a stated band (the zero band and the over band of 1×10⁻⁹, the target band of 1×10⁻⁵); a stability index within a factor of about 1.001 of 10¹⁰ or 100,000 may read differently in another engine.
Restrictions and non-computing states
Under NOT VALID every result and every table is blank, apart from the joints and members in use, the support reactions and determinacy degree (when items 1 to 11 pass, since they explain items 12 to 14), the model version, the challenge status (No challenge selected, or NOT MET when a challenge is selected), a score of 0, and the goal and hint of a selected challenge.
An unstable scan position shows its position and stability but no forces. A refinement step that is not run is a blank row, and the refinement table is blank when there is no bracket.
In challenge 1, until you predict, the results are held back as described under Challenges.
Errors and warnings
The status messages, first match wins (k, j, a and b are the lowest joint or member rows concerned):
- NOT VALID: joint k needs x and y from 0 to 20 m, a support from the list or blank, and loads from -1,000 to 1,000 kN or blank
- NOT VALID: joints j and k are closer than 0.05 m
- NOT VALID: at least two joints are needed
- NOT VALID: member b must join two different joints in use (whole joint numbers 1 to 8)
- NOT VALID: members a and b join the same two joints
- NOT VALID: at least one member is needed
- NOT VALID: joint k is not connected to any member
- NOT VALID: the modulus must be from 1 to 400 GPa, the area from 10 to 100,000 mm2, the second moment of area from 0.01 to 100,000 cm4, and each allowable force from 0.1 to 100,000 kN
- NOT VALID: the design joint must be a joint in use, the axis one of the listed choices, and the scan must run from a lower to a higher position, both from 0 to 20 m
- NOT VALID: the target member must be a member in use, and the target force from -100,000 to 100,000 kN
- NOT VALID: the challenge number must be a whole number from 0 to 5, and the prediction one of the listed choices
- NOT VALID: the supports give r reaction(s); a plane truss needs at least 3 to stop it sliding or turning
- NOT VALID: the truss is a mechanism: m members + r reactions = m+r, fewer than 2 x j joints = 2j, so it cannot hold its shape; add a member or a support: Maxwell's count, with the numbers filled in.
- NOT VALID: the truss is unstable: some joints can move without stretching any member (for example three joints in a line, or supports that all push the same way); its stability index is above 10^10
- CHECK: the truss is close to a mechanism (stability index above 100,000), so its forces are very large and change sharply with small moves
- CHECK: no load is applied, so every member force is 0
- CHECK: n member(s) are over the allowable force or buckle; see the member table
- OK
The inverse result reads one of:
- TARGET MET at a scan position: a scan position meets the target.
- TARGET MET by refinement inside the bracket: an Illinois step met the target.
- CHECK: the target lies between two scan positions but was not met within 4 refinement steps (the force may jump through an unstable position there); the closest point found is shown
- CHECK: the refinement reached an unstable position inside the bracket and stopped; the closest stable point found is shown
- CHECK: no scan position reaches the target force; the closest scan position is shown
- CHECK: every scan position leaves the truss unstable or makes a member shorter than 0.05 m; change the scan range
References
This laboratory is an educational model of a plane pin-jointed truss. It solves the truss by the direct stiffness method, assembling each member's axial stiffness into one matrix for the joint displacements and reading every member force from them, and it judges stability by the size of that matrix's inverse. It counts members and reactions against twice the joints (Maxwell's rule), checks each compression member against its ideal pin-ended Euler buckling load, and differentiates the stiffness equations to give each force's sensitivity to one joint coordinate. To meet a target force it scans that coordinate and refines the first bracket by the Illinois method, a modified regula falsi.
Sources and further reading
- Truss analysis by the equilibrium of the joints and by the displacement method, with the member stiffness and the assembled stiffness matrix: M. Cenanovic and C.-J. Jonsson, Applied Mechanics, Jönköping University, section 5.1, Truss analysis overview. Jönköping University
- The stiffness method set out systematically: element stiffness, transformation to global axes, assembly, supports, displacements, member forces and reactions: M. Cenanovic and C.-J. Jonsson, Applied Mechanics, Jönköping University, section 5.2, Automated truss analysis. Jönköping University
- Counting members, reactions and joints for determinacy, the degree of indeterminacy m + r - 2j, and why the count alone does not prove stability: J. Erochko, Learn About Structures, Carleton University, section 2.5, Internal Determinacy for Trusses. Learn About Structures
- The Euler buckling load of a pin-ended column, π² E I / L²: B. McGinty, Continuum Mechanics, Column Buckling. Continuum Mechanics
- The counting rule for frames: J. C. Maxwell, "On the calculation of the equilibrium and stiffness of frames", Philosophical Magazine 27, 1864, pages 294-299.
- The Illinois modification of regula falsi: M. Dowell and P. Jarratt, "A modified regula falsi method for computing the root of an equation", BIT Numerical Mathematics 11, 1971, pages 168-174.
No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.
This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; its allowable forces and ideal buckling loads are not a design check, so do not use it to size or check a real structure.
Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.
Found a problem, or have an idea?
Tell us if a result looks wrong, a label is unclear, or something is missing. We read every message.