Heat, fluids & energy

Heat Exchanger Tradeoff Lab

A water-to-water heat exchanger of 1 to 12 tubes of 1 to 12 m in parallel flow, counterflow, one-shell-pass shell and tube or crossflow: the tube side (laminar, Petukhov friction and Gnielinski heat transfer, thin-wall overall coefficient), the effectiveness by the closed-form epsilon-NTU relations, outlet temperatures, the temperature profile along the exchanger and a log-mean cross-check, pressure drop, pumping power and yearly cost; an exhaustive search of all 576 grid designs for the cheapest and the smallest that meet the duty, with the Pareto front and a search film. Five challenges are scored for you. For learning the trade between heat transfer, size and cost.

Last updated

Calculator overview

Inputs and outputs

This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.

Inputs

Required heat duty (required)
About this input

The heat the exchanger must move from the hot water to the cold, 1 to 2000 kW. A design meets the duty when its heat duty reaches it.

Unit kW Default 150 Range 1 to 2000
Shell-side film coefficient (required)
About this input

The heat transfer coefficient on the shell side of the tubes, 200 to 10000 W/(m2 K).

Unit W/(m² K) Default 5000 Range 200 to 10000
Hot water flow rate (required)
About this input

The hot water flow through the tubes, 0.05 to 5 kg/s.

Unit kg/s Default 1 Range 0.05 to 5
Hot inlet temperature (required)
About this input

The temperature of the hot water entering the tubes, 5 to 95 degrees C; at least 1 degree C hotter than the cold inlet.

Unit °C Default 90 Range 5 to 95
Tube length (required)
About this input

The length of each tube, 1 to 12 m. Set by dragging the end of the exchanger on the canvas.

Unit m Default 7 Range 1 to 12
Prediction: how the cheapest tube count moves at 0.60 dollars per kWh (required)
About this input

Challenge 4 only: your prediction of how the cheapest counterflow tube count moves when the energy price rises from 0.15 to 0.60 dollars per kWh (More tubes, Fewer tubes or No change). Not yet predicted until you choose; the search appears once you predict. Shown only in challenge 4.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, More tubes, Fewer tubes, No change
Number of tubes (required)
About this input

The number of tubes, 1 to 12. The hot flow is shared equally, so more tubes means slower water. Set with the tube-count handle on the canvas.

Default 4 Range 1 to 12
Tube inner diameter (required)
About this input

The inner diameter of every tube, 10 to 40 mm. Wider tubes give slower water, more area per metre and less friction.

Unit mm Default 20 Range 10 to 40
Fouling resistance (required)
About this input

The extra thermal resistance of deposits on the tubes, 0 (clean) to 0.001 m2 K/W.

Unit m² K/W Default 0 Range 0 to 0.001
Cold water flow rate (required)
About this input

The cold water flow through the shell, 0.05 to 5 kg/s.

Unit kg/s Default 1.5 Range 0.05 to 5
Cold inlet temperature (required)
About this input

The temperature of the cold water entering the shell, 5 to 95 degrees C.

Unit °C Default 20 Range 5 to 95
Installed cost of tube area (required)
About this input

The installed cost of one square metre of tube area, 50 to 2000 dollars; spread evenly over the lifetime.

Unit $/m² Default 400 Range 50 to 2000
Challenge number (required)
About this input

Selects a challenge: 0 for none, 1 to 5 for a predefined challenge, which fixes the settings except the inputs it leaves to you.

Default 0 Range 0 to 5
Equipment lifetime (required)
About this input

The years over which the area cost is spread (no interest), 1 to 40.

Unit years Default 10 Range 1 to 40
Flow arrangement (required)
About this input

How the two streams meet: Parallel flow (both enter at the same end), Counterflow (they enter at opposite ends), Shell and tube (one shell pass, each tube a U-tube of two passes) or Crossflow (the shell water crosses the tubes and is mixed). Chosen with the chips on the canvas.

Default Counterflow Allowed Parallel flow, Counterflow, Shell and tube, Crossflow
Prediction: can the cold outlet pass the hot outlet in parallel flow? (required)
About this input

Challenge 1 only: your prediction of whether, in parallel flow, the cold water can ever leave hotter than the hot water leaves (Yes or No). Not yet predicted until you choose; the temperatures appear once you predict. Shown only in challenge 1.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Yes, No
Energy price (required)
About this input

The price of the electricity that drives the pump, 0.01 to 1 dollar per kWh.

Unit $/kWh Default 0.15 Range 0.01 to 1

Outputs

Designs on the Pareto front
About this output

How many designs of the chosen arrangement are on the Pareto front: no other design moves at least as much heat for no more money. Blank while challenges 2, 3 and 5 are not met, while challenges 1 and 4 await a prediction, and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Parallel-flow limit
About this output

The largest effectiveness any parallel-flow exchanger can reach, 1/(1 + C_r). Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Overall heat transfer coefficient
About this output

The overall heat transfer coefficient U of your tubes (tube film, fouling and shell film in series), in W/(m2 K). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit W/(m² K)
Tube-side pressure drop
About this output

The friction pressure drop along your tubes, in kPa. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kPa
Required heat duty used
About this output

The required heat duty used, in kW. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kW
Pumping power
About this output

The power the pump needs to push the hot water through your tubes (70% efficient), in W. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit W
The temperature profile along the exchanger (parallel flow and counterflow; blank for the other two)
About this output

The two water temperatures at 41 positions along the exchanger (x/L from 0 to 1) for parallel flow and counterflow; blank for shell and tube and crossflow, and while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.

No unit declared
Closest duty to the duty line
About this output

How close the nearest of the 576 designs comes to the required duty, in percent; within 0.0001% the status reads CHECK. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit %
Log-mean temperature difference
About this output

The log-mean temperature difference of your design (parallel flow and counterflow), in degrees C. Blank for shell and tube and crossflow, while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit °C
Heat duty by the log-mean method
About this output

Your design's duty by the log-mean method, UA x LMTD, in kW: the same answer by a second method. Blank as for the log-mean temperature difference.

Unit kW
Hot outlet temperature
About this output

The temperature of the hot water leaving, in degrees C. Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit °C
Maximum possible duty
About this output

The most these two streams could ever exchange, C_min x (T_hi - T_ci), in kW. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kW
Formula module versions
About this output

The formula modules the model is built from, with their versions.

No unit declared
Model version
About this output

The model version.

No unit declared
Model Status
About this output

NOT VALID with the reason when an input cannot be used; CHECK when the duty is above what the streams can exchange, when no design on the grid (or of the chosen arrangement) meets it, when a duty, a cost or a Reynolds number lies within a hair of a decision line, when the cheapest design is at the edge of the grid, or when your tubes run faster than 3 m/s; otherwise OK.

No unit declared
Reynolds number
About this output

The Reynolds number of the water in your tubes. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
The tube side for each tube count: speed, Reynolds number, regime (1 laminar, 2 transitional, 3 turbulent), coefficients and pressure drop per metre
About this output

One row per tube count: the water speed, the Reynolds number, the regime code (1 laminar, 2 transitional, 3 turbulent), the tube-side and overall coefficients and the pressure drop per metre.

No unit declared
Tube-side film coefficient
About this output

The film coefficient inside your tubes, in W/(m2 K). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit W/(m² K)
Tube length used
About this output

The tube length used, in m. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Water speed in the tubes
About this output

The speed of the water in your tubes, in m/s; above 3 m/s the status warns of wear. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m/s
Yearly cost of pumping
About this output

The cost of the pumping energy for 8,000 hours a year, in dollars per year. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/yr
Yearly cost
About this output

Your design's yearly cost, area plus pumping, in dollars per year. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/yr
Yearly cost of the area
About this output

The installed cost of your tube area spread over the lifetime, in dollars per year. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/yr
Tube inner diameter used
About this output

The tube inner diameter used, in mm. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit mm
Smallest design: area
About this output

The tube area of the smallest design of the chosen arrangement that meets the duty, in m2. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

Unit m²
Shell-side film coefficient used
About this output

The shell-side film coefficient used, in W/(m2 K). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit W/(m² K)
The search film: design by design, the cheapest design so far that meets the duty
About this output

One frame per design, in the same order: the frame number, the cheapest yearly cost found so far among designs that meet the duty, and the row of that design (blank until one meets it). Columns 2 and 3 blank as for the design cloud.

No unit declared
Smallest design: length
About this output

The tube length of the smallest design that meets the duty, in m. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

Unit m
Number of tubes used
About this output

The tube count used. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Number of transfer units (NTU)
About this output

The number of transfer units NTU = UA/C_min of your design. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Smallest design: tubes
About this output

The tube count of the smallest design that meets the duty (fewest tubes among equal areas). Blank as for the cheapest cost.

No unit declared
Cheapest design: heat duty
About this output

The heat duty of the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement, in kW. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

Unit kW
Cheapest design: yearly cost
About this output

The yearly cost of the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement that meets the duty, in dollars per year. Blank when none meets it, while challenges 2 and 3 are not met, while challenges 1 and 4 await a prediction, and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/yr
Cheapest design: area
About this output

The tube area of the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement, in m2. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

Unit m²
Cheapest design: length
About this output

The tube length of the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement that meets the duty, in m. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

Unit m
Cold water flow rate used
About this output

The cold water flow rate used, in kg/s. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kg/s
Cheapest design: tubes
About this output

The tube count of the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement that meets the duty. Blank as for the cheapest cost.

No unit declared
Runner-up cost gap
About this output

How much dearer the second cheapest design of the chosen arrangement is than the cheapest, in percent. Blank with fewer than two designs that meet the duty, and as for the cheapest cost.

Unit %
Challenge result
About this output

No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.

No unit declared
Capacity ratio
About this output

The capacity ratio C_min/C_max of the two streams, 0 to 1. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Your geometry in each arrangement, and each arrangement's cheapest and smallest design that meets the duty
About this output

One row per arrangement: your geometry's effectiveness, duty and outlets in that arrangement (blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction), and that arrangement's cheapest design (cost, tubes, length) and smallest area that meet the duty (blank when none meets it, while challenges 2 and 3 are not met and while challenges 1 and 4 await a prediction).

No unit declared
Installed cost of tube area used
About this output

The installed cost of tube area used, in dollars per m2. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/m²
Challenge feedback
About this output

Feedback on the selected challenge: the prompt while a prediction is awaited, else the met text or the not-met hint (blank with none).

No unit declared
Challenge score
About this output

The challenge score: 100 when met, else 0.

No unit declared
Challenge: the value scored
About this output

The value the selected challenge scores: the outlet difference (1), your area (2), your yearly cost (3), the cheapest counterflow tube count at 0.60 dollars per kWh (4) or your effectiveness (5); blank with none, while a prediction is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Challenge goal
About this output

The goal of the selected challenge (blank with none).

No unit declared
Cold inlet temperature used
About this output

The cold inlet temperature used, in degrees C. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit °C
Fouling resistance used
About this output

The fouling resistance used, in m2 K/W. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m² K/W
Flow regime
About this output

Laminar (Reynolds number below 2,300), Transitional (2,300 to 10,000, where the correlation is uncertain) or Turbulent. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Flow arrangement used
About this output

The flow arrangement used (a challenge may set its own). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Heat duty
About this output

The heat your design moves, in kW. Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kW
Hot inlet temperature used
About this output

The hot inlet temperature used, in degrees C. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit °C
Hot water flow rate used
About this output

The hot water flow rate used, in kg/s. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit kg/s
Heat transfer area
About this output

The tube area of your design, n x L x PI x D, in m2. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m²
Designs that meet the duty
About this output

How many of the 144 designs of the chosen arrangement meet the required duty. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Duty margin
About this output

How far your design's duty is above (+) or below (-) the required duty, in percent. Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit %
The design cloud: every design of the chosen arrangement, its duty and yearly cost, whether it meets the duty and whether it is on the Pareto front
About this output

One row per design of the chosen arrangement (fewest tubes first, then shortest): the tubes, the length, the heat duty, the yearly cost, 1 when it meets the duty and 1 when it is on the Pareto front. Blank while challenges 2, 3 and 5 are not met and while challenges 1 and 4 await a prediction.

No unit declared
Cold outlet temperature
About this output

The temperature of the cold water leaving, in degrees C. Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit °C
Effectiveness against NTU for the four arrangements at the current capacity ratio
About this output

Effectiveness against NTU from 0 to 5 for the four arrangements at the current capacity ratio. Columns 2 to 5 blank while challenge 5 is not met and while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.

No unit declared
Effectiveness
About this output

Your design's effectiveness: the heat it moves over the most these two streams could ever exchange, 0 to 1. Blank while challenge 1 awaits a prediction and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Equipment lifetime used
About this output

The equipment lifetime used, in years. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit years
Energy price used
About this output

The energy price used, in dollars per kWh. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit $/kWh
This page is provided by LogicCommons for informational purposes only. Results are analysis outputs computed from the inputs you supply and are not professional advice. Verify all inputs and results independently.

LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.

Methodology

Purpose and model boundary

This lab sizes a water-to-water heat exchanger. Hot water flows through a bundle of 1 to 12 tubes, each 1 to 12 m long, inside a shell that carries cold water, in one of four arrangements: parallel flow, counterflow, a one-shell-pass shell and tube exchanger, or crossflow. For your design the model returns the tube-side flow (speed, Reynolds number, regime and film coefficient), the overall coefficient, the effectiveness by the closed-form effectiveness-NTU relations, the heat duty and both outlet temperatures, the temperature profile along the exchanger, a second duty by the log-mean method, the pressure drop, the pumping power and the yearly cost. It also searches all 576 designs on the grid (12 tube counts, 12 lengths, 4 arrangements) for the cheapest design and the smallest design that meet the required duty, and shows the designs of the chosen arrangement as a cloud of duty against cost with its Pareto front and a search film. Five scored challenges go with it.

It is a lab for learning the trade between heat transfer, size and cost: why counterflow moves the most heat for the same tubes, why parallel flow can never take the cold water past the hot outlet, and why more, slower tubes cost more in area but less in pumping. It is not a design method for a real exchanger: both streams are water with fixed properties, the shell side is a single given coefficient, and only the tube side has a pressure drop.

The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what it returns: the exchanger schematic with its inlet and outlet temperatures, the temperature profile, the design cloud, the search film and the effectiveness curves all come from the model's own results. The page computes no effectiveness, duty, temperature or cost itself.

Inputs and units

Input Meaning and unit
Flow arrangement Parallel flow (both streams enter at the same end), Counterflow (default; they enter at opposite ends), Shell and tube (one shell pass, each tube a U-tube of two passes) or Crossflow (the shell water crosses the tubes and is mixed).
Number of tubes A whole number from 1 to 12 (default 4). The hot flow is shared equally, so more tubes means slower water.
Tube length A whole number of metres from 1 to 12 (default 7 m).
Hot inlet temperature From 5 to 95 °C (default 90 °C), at least 1 °C hotter than the cold inlet.
Cold inlet temperature From 5 to 95 °C (default 20 °C).
Hot water flow rate Through the tubes, from 0.05 to 5 kg/s (default 1 kg/s).
Cold water flow rate Through the shell, from 0.05 to 5 kg/s (default 1.5 kg/s).
Required heat duty From 1 to 2,000 kW (default 150 kW): the heat the exchanger must move. A design meets the duty when its heat duty reaches it.
Tube inner diameter From 10 to 40 mm (default 20 mm).
Shell-side film coefficient From 200 to 10,000 W/(m² K) (default 5,000).
Fouling resistance From 0 (clean, the default) to 0.001 m² K/W.
Installed cost of tube area From 50 to 2,000 dollars per m² (default 400).
Equipment lifetime A whole number of years from 1 to 40 (default 10), over which the area cost is spread evenly, with no interest.
Energy price The price of the electricity that drives the pump, from 0.01 to 1 dollar per kWh (default 0.15).
Challenge number 0 for free exploration, or 1 to 5 to load a challenge.
Prediction: can the cold outlet pass the hot outlet in parallel flow? Challenge 1 only: Not yet predicted (the start), Yes or No.
Prediction: how the cheapest tube count moves at 0.60 dollars per kWh Challenge 4 only: Not yet predicted (the start), More tubes, Fewer tubes or No change.

Where each input is set:

  • On the canvas only: the flow arrangement (chips showing the four outlines), the number of tubes (the tube-count handle on the end view) and the tube length (by dragging the end of the exchanger), both in whole steps. Each prediction is a set of buttons shown only in its own challenge. None of these is in the input panel.
  • In the input panel: the two streams in one small table (inlet temperature and flow rate for the hot and the cold water, each set with a slider in a popup), the required duty, the tube diameter, the shell-side coefficient, the fouling resistance, the three cost inputs and the challenge number.

Governing relationships

Water properties. Both streams are liquid water with constant properties at 50 °C: density ρ = 988 kg/m³, specific heat c_p = 4,181 J/(kg K), viscosity μ = 0.000547 Pa s and conductivity k = 0.644 W/(m K). The Prandtl number Pr = μ·c_p/k (about 3.551) is computed from them.

Stream capacities. C_h = m_h·c_p and C_c = m_c·c_p (W/K); C_min and C_max are the smaller and larger; the capacity ratio is C_r = C_min/C_max, from 0 to 1. The most the two streams could ever exchange is Q_max = C_min·(T_hi - T_ci).

The tube side, for n tubes of inner diameter D:

  • each tube carries m_h/n; its speed is v = (m_h/n) / (ρ·π·D²/4) and its Reynolds number Re = 4·(m_h/n) / (π·D·μ);
  • laminar flow (Re below 2,300): the Darcy friction factor f = 64/Re and the Nusselt number Nu = 3.66 (fully developed flow at a constant wall temperature);
  • otherwise: f by Petukhov's formula, f = (0.79·ln Re - 1.64)⁻², and Nu by Gnielinski's correlation, Nu = (f/8)·(Re - 1000)·Pr / (1 + 12.7·√(f/8)·(Pr^(2/3) - 1)), never below 3.66. The model labels Re from 2,300 to 10,000 transitional, where the correlation is uncertain, and above that turbulent;
  • the tube-side coefficient h_i = Nu·k/D, and the overall coefficient on the tube area (thin wall) is U = 1 / (1/h_i + R_f + 1/h_o), with R_f the fouling resistance and h_o the shell-side coefficient;
  • the pressure drop per metre is (f/D)·(ρ·v²/2), and the pressure drop of a tube of length L is L times that.

Area, NTU and costs. The heat transfer area is A = n·L·π·D and the number of transfer units NTU = U·A/C_min. The pumping power is the pressure drop times the hot volume flow, over a pump efficiency of 70%. The yearly cost is the area cost (the installed cost per m² times A, over the lifetime) plus the pumping cost (the pumping power in kW times 8,000 hours a year times the energy price).

Effectiveness (the effectiveness-NTU method). The effectiveness ε is the heat moved over Q_max. For the four arrangements:

  • parallel flow: ε = (1 - e^(-NTU·(1 + C_r))) / (1 + C_r);
  • counterflow: ε = (1 - e^(-NTU·(1 - C_r))) / (1 - C_r·e^(-NTU·(1 - C_r))), which is NTU/(1 + NTU) when C_r = 1;
  • shell and tube, one shell pass and an even number of tube passes, with s = √(1 + C_r²): ε = 2 / (1 + C_r + s·(1 + e^(-NTU·s)) / (1 - e^(-NTU·s)));
  • crossflow with the shell (cold) stream mixed and the tube stream unmixed: when the cold stream is C_max, ε = (1/C_r)·(1 - exp(-C_r·(1 - e^(-NTU)))); when it is C_min, ε = 1 - exp(-(1/C_r)·(1 - e^(-C_r·NTU))).

The model writes these with E(z) = (1 - e^(-z))/z, using a short series below z = 0.01, so that none of them loses digits near C_r = 1 or at small NTU, and caps ε at 1. For the same tubes counterflow always has the highest effectiveness. No parallel-flow exchanger, however long, can exceed 1/(1 + C_r), the parallel-flow limit.

Duty and outlets. The heat duty is Q = ε·Q_max; the hot outlet is T_hi - Q/C_h and the cold outlet T_ci + Q/C_c. The duty margin is 100·(Q/Q_req - 1), in %.

Temperature profile. For parallel flow and counterflow the two-stream equations along the exchanger have a closed-form solution, evaluated at 41 positions x/L = 0, 1/40, ... 1, with no step-by-step integration. In counterflow it is anchored at the end with the larger temperature difference. With equal flows in counterflow the two lines are parallel straight lines. Shell and tube and crossflow have no one-dimensional profile, so the model gives none.

The log-mean method. For parallel flow and counterflow, the log-mean temperature difference of the two end differences, LMTD = (ΔT_a - ΔT_b) / ln(ΔT_a/ΔT_b), gives a second duty, U·A·LMTD, which equals the effectiveness duty.

The search. Every one of the 144 tube count and length pairs is costed once and rated in all four arrangements. A design meets the duty when Q ≥ Q_req·(1 - 1×10⁻⁹). For each arrangement the cheapest design that meets the duty is the one with the lowest yearly cost (the earlier design on an exact tie, fewest tubes first, then shortest), and the smallest is the one with the least n·L (fewest tubes among equal areas). The search film runs through the chosen arrangement's 144 designs in that order and keeps the cheapest design so far that meets the duty. A design is on the Pareto front when no other design of the arrangement moves at least as much heat for no more money (with bands of one part in a billion).

Calculation sequence

  1. The model checks your values in the order of the status list under Errors and warnings, up to the challenge number and the two predictions.
  2. It fixes the values in use: yours, or in a challenge the challenge's, except the inputs that challenge leaves free.
  3. It computes the stream capacities, Q_max, the capacity ratio and the parallel-flow limit.
  4. For each tube count from 1 to 12 it computes the speed, Reynolds number, regime, friction factor, Nusselt number, film and overall coefficients and pressure drop per metre.
  5. For each of the 144 tube count and length pairs it computes the area, NTU, pressure drop, pumping power and costs, and in each arrangement the effectiveness and duty and whether the design meets the required duty.
  6. It searches each arrangement for its cheapest and smallest design that meets the duty, builds the search film, the design cloud and the Pareto front, and finds how close any design comes to the duty line.
  7. It reads your design from the same table, with its outlets, profile, log-mean check and the effectiveness curves.
  8. It sets the status and, in a challenge, scores the challenge and withholds what the challenge keeps back.

Outputs and interpretation

  • Your design: the effectiveness (0 to 1), the heat duty (kW), the yearly cost ($ per year, split into the yearly cost of the area and of pumping), the hot and cold outlet temperatures (°C), the duty margin (%), the heat transfer area (m²), NTU, the water speed in the tubes (m/s), the Reynolds number and flow regime, the tube-side film coefficient and the overall coefficient (W/(m² K)), the pressure drop (kPa) and the pumping power (W).
  • The streams: the capacity ratio, the maximum possible duty (kW) and the parallel-flow limit, 1/(1 + C_r).
  • The search, for the chosen arrangement: the designs that meet the duty (of 144), the cheapest design (its tubes, length, yearly cost, duty and area), the runner-up cost gap (%), the smallest design (its tubes, length and area), the designs on the Pareto front, and the closest duty to the duty line (%) over all 576 designs.
  • Arrangement table: for each arrangement, your geometry's effectiveness, duty and outlets, and that arrangement's cheapest and smallest design that meet the duty.
  • Tube table: for each tube count, the speed, Reynolds number, regime code (1 laminar, 2 transitional, 3 turbulent), tube-side and overall coefficients and pressure drop per metre.
  • Design cloud: the chosen arrangement's 144 designs (fewest tubes first, then shortest), each with its duty, yearly cost, whether it meets the duty and whether it is on the Pareto front; and the search film, frame by frame, with the cheapest design so far.
  • Temperature profile (41 positions; parallel flow and counterflow only), the log-mean temperature difference and the duty by the log-mean method, and the effectiveness curves of the four arrangements against NTU from 0 to 5 at the current capacity ratio.
  • Settings used and the model and module versions.

Reading the canvas: the schematic shows the chosen arrangement, the tubes and their length, and the inlet and outlet temperatures; for parallel flow and counterflow the profile shows how the two water temperatures change along the exchanger. The cloud plots each design's duty against its yearly cost with the required duty as a line and the cheapest design marked; the film replays the search.

What to take from the lab: for the same tubes, counterflow moves the most heat, because the cold water meets ever hotter water, and it can take the cold outlet above the hot outlet; parallel flow never can and never passes 1/(1 + C_r). Area costs money every year and so does pumping, and pumping power rises steeply with the water speed, so the cheapest design balances fewer, faster tubes against more, slower ones, and dearer energy pushes it toward more tubes.

Challenges

Each challenge uses the standard streams (hot 90 °C at 1 kg/s, cold 20 °C at 1.5 kg/s), a 150 kW duty, 20 mm tubes, a shell-side coefficient of 5,000 W/(m² K), clean tubes, 400 dollars per m², 10 years and 0.15 dollars per kWh, unless it says otherwise, and leaves the inputs it names to you. The model scores each one MET (100) or NOT MET (0) and gives a one-line hint while it is not met.

  1. Predict the crossover (introductory). Parallel flow; you may change the tubes and length. Predict: in parallel flow, can the cold water ever leave hotter than the hot water leaves? It is met when you answer No. The value scored is the hot outlet minus the cold outlet (°C).
  2. Smallest exchanger (intermediate). Counterflow: meet the 150 kW duty with the smallest heat transfer area. It is met when your design meets the duty and no design on the grid with less area does. The value scored is your area.
  3. Cheapest that works (advanced). Any arrangement: meet the 150 kW duty at a yearly cost within 2% of the cheapest design on the grid. The value scored is your yearly cost.
  4. Which way does it move? (intermediate). The energy price rises from 0.15 to 0.60 dollars per kWh. Predict: does the cheapest counterflow design use more tubes, fewer tubes, or the same number as at 0.15 (3 tubes)? It is met when your prediction matches the cheapest counterflow tube count at 0.60. The value scored is that tube count.
  5. Beat the parallel limit (intermediate). Equal flows, 4 tubes, counterflow: find the shortest exchanger whose effectiveness beats 0.5, the most any parallel-flow exchanger can reach here. It is met when your effectiveness is above 0.5 and one metre shorter is not (or your length is 1 m). The value scored is your effectiveness.

Held-back results. While challenge 1 awaits your prediction, the effectiveness, duty, outlets, parallel-flow limit, duty margin, log-mean values, the profile temperatures, the effectiveness columns of the arrangement table, the effectiveness curves and every search result are blank, and the schematic is drawn without temperature colours. The search results (cheapest and smallest designs, runner-up gap, Pareto count, the cloud, the film and the search columns of the arrangement table) are also blank while challenge 2 or 3 is not met and while challenge 4 awaits your prediction. Challenge 5 withholds the effectiveness curves, the cloud, the film and the Pareto count until it is met. Your own design's results stay visible to work with. Once you predict in challenge 1 or 4, everything shows, met or not.

Validation and status logic

The status reads the first match in the list under Errors and warnings. The NOT VALID checks read the values you entered, whether or not the current state uses them; the CHECK items read the values in use and apply inside challenges too. A challenge number that is not a whole number from 0 to 5 counts as no challenge selected.

Assumptions and limitations

  • Water to water, with constant properties at 50 °C, and inlets from 5 to 95 °C.
  • Tube side: fully developed flow, with Nu 3.66 and f = 64/Re below Re 2,300, and Petukhov friction with Gnielinski heat transfer from 2,300 up; between 2,300 and about 3,000 that is outside the correlation's stated range, and the model labels 2,300 to 10,000 transitional. Laminar Nu jumps up at 2,300, as in the transition itself.
  • The overall coefficient is a thin-wall series sum on the tube area; there is no wall resistance. The shell-side coefficient is an input, and the shell side has no pressure drop. There are no minor losses.
  • The arrangement changes only the effectiveness: the four arrangements of one geometry share area, speed, pressure drop and cost. Crossflow with both streams unmixed is not offered.
  • Pumping at 70% efficiency for 8,000 hours a year; the area cost is spread evenly over the lifetime with no interest. Costs are illustrative.
  • The search covers whole tube counts and whole metres from 1 to 12; a cheaper design may exist off the grid, and the edge warning says when that is likely.
  • A value within about 1×10⁻⁹ (relative) of a threshold may flip a decision; the CHECK items name the cases where it could.

Restrictions and non-computing states

Under NOT VALID every result and every table is blank, except the model and module versions; the challenge status (No challenge selected, or NOT MET when a challenge is selected), a score of 0, and the goal and not-met hint of a selected challenge.

When no design of the chosen arrangement meets the duty, the cheapest and smallest design results are blank.

In challenges 1 to 5 the results listed under Challenges stay blank until the challenge allows them.

Errors and warnings

The status messages, first match wins:

  • NOT VALID: choose a flow arrangement from the list
  • NOT VALID: each inlet temperature must be from 5 to 95 degrees C, with the hot inlet at least 1 degree C hotter than the cold inlet
  • NOT VALID: each flow rate must be from 0.05 to 5 kg/s
  • NOT VALID: the required duty must be from 1 to 2000 kW
  • NOT VALID: the tube count and the tube length must be whole numbers from 1 to 12
  • NOT VALID: the tube diameter must be from 10 to 40 mm, the shell-side coefficient from 200 to 10000 W/(m2 K) and the fouling resistance from 0 to 0.001 m2 K/W
  • NOT VALID: the area cost must be from 50 to 2000 dollars per m2, the lifetime a whole number of years from 1 to 40 and the energy price from 0.01 to 1 dollar per kWh
  • NOT VALID: the challenge number must be a whole number from 0 to 5, and each prediction one of the listed choices
  • CHECK: the required duty is above the most these two streams can exchange (the maximum possible duty), so no exchanger of any size can meet it: a lesson, not an error.
  • CHECK: no design on the grid (1 to 12 tubes, 1 to 12 m) meets the required duty in any arrangement; lower the duty, or try wider tubes or a better shell side
  • CHECK: no design of the chosen arrangement on the grid meets the required duty; other arrangements do (see the arrangement table)
  • CHECK: some design's heat duty is within one part in a million of the required duty, so whether it meets the duty could differ between calculators
  • CHECK: the two cheapest designs of one arrangement cost within one part in a billion of each other, so which one is shown as cheapest could differ between calculators
  • CHECK: a tube count gives a Reynolds number within one part in a billion of 2,300 or 10,000, where the flow regime changes, so its heat transfer could differ between calculators
  • CHECK: the cheapest design of the chosen arrangement is at the edge of the grid (12 tubes, or a length of 1 m or 12 m), so a larger grid might find a cheaper one
  • CHECK: the water in your design's tubes runs faster than 3 m/s, which would wear real tubes; the model still computes it
  • OK

A blank list choice is refused by the page before the model runs.

References

This laboratory is an educational model of a water-to-water heat exchanger. It rates each design by the effectiveness-NTU method, with the closed-form effectiveness of parallel flow, counterflow, a one-shell-pass shell and tube exchanger and crossflow with one stream mixed, and checks the duty by the log-mean temperature difference. The tube side uses the laminar results for fully developed pipe flow, Petukhov's friction factor and Gnielinski's correlation for turbulent heat transfer, and a thin-wall overall coefficient. An exhaustive search of a grid of designs weighs the yearly cost of tube area against the cost of pumping.

Sources and further reading

  • Heat exchanger configurations, the mean temperature difference, heat exchanger effectiveness, and heat transfer in laminar and turbulent pipe flow: J. H. Lienhard IV and J. H. Lienhard V, A Heat Transfer Textbook, 6th edition, 2024, chapter 3, sections 3.1 to 3.3, and chapter 7, sections 7.2 and 7.3. MIT textbook site, table of contents
  • The log-mean temperature difference and the efficiency of a counterflow heat exchanger: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Thermodynamics and Propulsion course notes, section 18.5, Heat Exchangers. MIT
  • Thermophysical properties of liquid water (density, specific heat, viscosity and thermal conductivity): National Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST Chemistry WebBook, Standard Reference Database 69, Thermophysical Properties of Fluid Systems. NIST
  • The friction factor for turbulent pipe flow: B. S. Petukhov, "Heat transfer and friction in turbulent pipe flow with variable physical properties", Advances in Heat Transfer 6, Academic Press, 1970, pages 503-564.
  • The turbulent heat transfer correlation: V. Gnielinski, "Neue Gleichungen für den Wärme- und den Stoffübergang in turbulent durchströmten Rohren und Kanälen", Forschung im Ingenieurwesen 41(1), 1975, pages 8-16.
  • Effectiveness-NTU relations for many flow arrangements: W. M. Kays and A. L. London, Compact Heat Exchangers, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill, 1984.

No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.

This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; a real exchanger needs the shell-side flow, wall, fouling and pressure drop worked out for its own geometry and fluids.

Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.

Results are informational and not professional advice. See our Terms of Use. Powered by SpreadsheetWeb · About · Privacy · Terms