Physics Lab 101

Floating and Sinking: Do Heavy Things Sink?

A Physics Lab 101 lab that tests the belief that heavy things sink: guess whether an object floats or sinks and how far up its side the liquid comes, then watch a 3 kg steel ship float while a 79 g steel bolt sinks. Six objects in five liquids on Earth, the Moon or Mars give the density beside the liquid's, the share under the surface by Archimedes' principle, the waterline of a block or a ball by the exact cubic root, the forces at rest and held under, an illustrative settling or sinking film, a verdict on the guess and a one-sentence Why? chosen from the previous run. Four challenges are scored by the model, ending with a mystery block, already floating in honey, whose density you work out from its waterline.

Last updated

Calculator overview

Inputs and outputs

This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.

Inputs

Previous run: world
When omitted Blank
About this input

The world of your previous run, sent by the page and never typed (blank on the first run). Used only to choose the Why? sentence; a text that is not a listed world counts as no previous run.

Default Not set
Previous run: object
When omitted Blank
About this input

The object of your previous run, sent by the page and never typed (blank on the first run). Used only to choose the Why? sentence; a text that is not a listed object counts as no previous run.

Default Not set
Previous run: liquid
When omitted Blank
About this input

The liquid of your previous run, sent by the page and never typed (blank on the first run). Used only to choose the Why? sentence; a text that is not a listed liquid counts as no previous run.

Default Not set
World (required)
About this input

Where the tank stands: Earth, the Moon or Mars. Gravity changes the forces and the settling time, but not how deep a floater sits. Chosen with the world chips on the canvas.

Default Earth Allowed Earth, Moon, Mars
Your guess: how much of it sits below the surface
When omitted Blank
About this input

Read only with Floats: how far up the side of the object you think the liquid will come, 0 to 100% of its height, set by dragging the dotted waterline. Optional: Floats without a waterline is a valid guess and scores the float or sink part only.

Unit % Default Not set Range 0 to 100
Your pick: which one sinks (required)
About this input

Challenge 1 only: which one sinks in water, The ship, The bolt, Both or Neither, picked by clicking on the canvas and then locked in. It starts as Not yet predicted (a blank is read the same way).

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, The ship, The bolt, Both, Neither
Object (required)
About this input

The object: Pine block, Ice block, Apple, Steel toy ship, Stone or Steel bolt. Each shelf label gives its name and mass, never its density. Picked from the shelf beside the tank on the canvas.

Default Steel toy ship Allowed Pine block, Ice block, Apple, Steel toy ship, Stone, Steel bolt
Units shown (required)
About this input

Metric or Imperial: the densities in kg/m^3 or lb/ft^3, the mass in kg or lb and the forces in N or lbf. Everything is computed in metric; shares and times do not change. Chosen with the units chips on the canvas; it never clears your guess.

Default Metric Allowed Metric, Imperial
Your guess: the block's density
When omitted Blank
About this input

Challenge 4 only: your guess for the mystery block's density, 0 to 3000 kg/m^3, placed with the marker on the density ruler and locked in. Blank until you guess; a guess within 5% meets the challenge.

Unit kg/m^3 Default Not set Range 0 to 3000
Challenge number (required)
About this input

0 for Play; 1 to 4 load a challenge (1: the steel ship and the steel bolt; 2: make steel float; 3: an iceberg on the Moon; 4: the mystery block). Chosen with the tabs above the canvas.

Default 0 Range 0 to 4
Mystery block number (required)
About this input

Challenge 4 only: the number of the mystery block, a whole number from 0 to 999, which picks its hidden density. The New mystery block button steps it and clears your density guess.

Default 0 Range 0 to 999
Liquid in the tank (required)
About this input

The liquid in the tank: Water, Sea water, Cooking oil, Honey or Mercury, at typical room-temperature densities shown on the jug labels. Picked from the jug shelf above the tank on the canvas.

Default Water Allowed Water, Sea water, Cooking oil, Honey, Mercury
Your guess: does it float or sink? (required)
About this input

Play and challenge 3: your guess, Floats or Sinks, picked with the chips on the tank wall. It starts as Not yet predicted (a blank is read the same way); the results stay hidden until you lock in a guess. Changing the object, liquid or world clears it.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Floats, Sinks

Outputs

Your guess
About this output

How your guess did: right or not quite on floats or sinks, and for a floater with a waterline guess, spot on (within 5% of its height), close (within 15%) or not quite. In challenge 1 the verdict on your pick. Blank until you guess.

No unit declared
Object used
About this output

The object used (a challenge may set its own; in challenge 4 the Mystery block). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Time to settle (illustrative)
About this output

An illustrative time for a floater to settle within 1% of its depth, in seconds; real objects bob a little first. Blank for a sinker, until you guess, in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

Unit s
Mass
About this output

The mass of the object, in kg (lb in Imperial units). Shown before you guess, as on the shelf label, because weight is what most people expect to matter. Blank in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

Unit kg
Net force if held under and let go
About this output

The net force if the object is held fully under and let go, in N (lbf), up positive: the push up when fully under minus the weight. Positive means it rises, negative that it sinks. Blank as weightForce.

Unit N
Density: object
About this output

The density of the object, how heavy each bit of it is, in kg/m^3 (lb/ft^3 in Imperial units): its mass divided by its volume. Blank until you guess, in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find it.

Unit kg/m^3
Object height used
About this output

The height of the object used, in m (the diameter for the apple); the canvas draws the object and its 1 cm ticks from it. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Why?
About this output

One plain sentence on why it floated or sank. When exactly one thing changed since your previous run it says what that change did; otherwise it explains the run on its own. Play only; blank until you guess.

No unit declared
How we got this
About this output

How we got this: the working behind the numbers, one step per line, each equation with this run's numbers and the result, in metric with the Imperial result in brackets in Imperial units. Hidden until you lock in a guess, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

No unit declared
World used
About this output

The world used (a challenge may set its own). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Why? case
About this output

The code of the Why? sentence chosen, W01 to W17 (for testing; not shown on the page). Blank whenever the Why? sentence is blank.

No unit declared
Share under the surface
About this output

The share of the object's volume under the surface, in percent: its density divided by the liquid's for a floater, 100 for a sinker. Blank until you guess, in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

Unit %
Waterline, share of the height
About this output

How far up the apple's side the liquid comes when it floats, in percent of its height: not the same as the share under, because a ball is wider in the middle. Blank for a straight-sided block, where it equals the share under, and for a sinker; also blank until you guess, in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

Unit %
Weight
About this output

The weight of the object, its mass times gravity, in N (lbf in Imperial units). Blank until you guess, in challenge 1, and in challenge 4 until you find the density.

Unit N
Formula module versions
About this output

The formula modules and their versions.

No unit declared
Challenge: the waterline found
About this output

Challenge 3: the waterline found on the ice block, in percent of its height, after you lock in your guess. Blank otherwise.

Unit %
Challenge score
About this output

The challenge score: 100 when met, otherwise 0.

No unit declared
Challenge result
About this output

No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.

No unit declared
Challenge: the mystery density
About this output

Challenge 4: the mystery block's real density, in kg/m^3 (lb/ft^3 in Imperial units), shown only once your guess is within 5%. Blank otherwise.

Unit kg/m^3
Push up at rest (buoyancy)
About this output

The push up from the liquid when the object is at rest, in N (lbf): equal to the weight for a floater; for a sinker the push up when fully under, with the floor holding up the rest. Blank as weightForce.

Unit N
Challenge feedback
About this output

What to try next, or why the challenge is met. While a challenge waits for your guess or pick it asks for it. Blank in Play.

No unit declared
Challenge goal
About this output

The goal of the selected challenge. Blank in Play.

No unit declared
Liquid used
About this output

The liquid used (a challenge may set its own). Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Model Status
About this output

OK, CHECK (its density is within 1% of the liquid's, so it only just floats or only just sinks; every result still shows) or NOT VALID with the reason (the results are then blank).

No unit declared
Model version
About this output

The version of this model.

No unit declared
Density: liquid
About this output

The density of the liquid in the tank, in kg/m^3 (lb/ft^3 in Imperial units), the same as its jug label. Blank in challenge 1.

Unit kg/m^3
Units used
About this output

The units the cards are shown in, Metric or Imperial. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
The dip, frame by frame: the time and how deep the bottom of the object is (in challenge 1, the ship and the bolt)
About this output

The dip frame by frame, 121 rows: the time and how deep the bottom of the object is below the surface (in challenge 1 the ship and the bolt side by side; in challenge 4 to the millimetre on a fixed 2.0 s film). Only row 0, the object held at the surface, is shown until you guess.

No unit declared
What happened
About this output

What happened: Floats or Sinks, with only just added when the densities are within 1% of each other. Blank until you lock in a guess and in challenge 1.

No unit declared
This page is provided by LogicCommons for informational purposes only. Results are analysis outputs computed from the inputs you supply and are not professional advice. Verify all inputs and results independently.

LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.

Methodology

Purpose and model boundary

Many people think heavy things sink and light things float. This lab tests that idea. You put an object in a tank of liquid, on Earth, the Moon or Mars. Before you let go you make your guess: will it float or sink, and if it floats, how far up its side will the liquid come? Then the lab shows what really happens. A 3 kg steel toy ship floats, while a 79 g steel bolt sinks.

The lab is for learning that density, not weight, decides whether something floats. It uses simple, stated values for each object and typical values for each liquid at room temperature. It does not predict a real object exactly: real objects bob, tip and soak up liquid, and real liquids change with temperature.

The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what it sends back: the object settling in the tank or dropping to the floor, and in the challenges the ship and the bolt side by side and the mystery block. The page works out no density, depth or force itself.

Inputs and units

Input Meaning and unit
Object Pine block (1.000 kg, 20 × 10 × 10 cm), Ice block (0.917 kg, a 10 cm cube), Apple (0.180 kg, a ball 7.5 cm across), Steel toy ship (3.000 kg, a closed hull 30 × 20 × 10 cm), Stone (0.054 kg, 4 × 2.5 × 2 cm) or Steel bolt (0.0785 kg, 5 × 1 × 2 cm). Default: Steel toy ship.
Liquid in the tank Water (998 kg/m³), Sea water (1,025), Cooking oil (920), Honey (1,420) or Mercury (13,546). Default: Water.
World Earth, Moon or Mars (default Earth).
Your guess: floats or sinks Free play and challenge 3: Floats or Sinks. It starts as Not yet predicted.
Your guess: the waterline Used only with Floats: how far up the object's side the liquid will come, from 0 to 100% of its height. It is optional.
Your pick: which one sinks Challenge 1 only: The ship, The bolt, Both or Neither. It starts as Not yet predicted.
Mystery block number Challenge 4 only: a whole number from 0 to 999 (default 0) that chooses the mystery block.
Your guess: the block's density Challenge 4 only: from 0 to 3,000 kg/m³. It starts empty.
Previous run (object, liquid, world) The setup of your last run, sent by the page and never typed. They are used only to choose the Why? sentence.
Units shown Metric or Imperial (default Metric). Imperial shows densities in pounds per cubic foot, the mass in pounds and the forces in pounds of force.
Challenge number 0 for free play, or 1 to 4 to load a challenge (default 0).

Where each input is set:

  • On the canvas only: everything you choose. You pick an object from the shelf, a jug of liquid and a world, tap It floats or It sinks on the tank wall, drag the dotted waterline, and press Lock in my guess. In challenge 1 you click the ship or the bolt (or Both or Neither); in challenge 4 you press New mystery block and drag your guess along the density ruler. The units are two small buttons. The lab has no input panel.
  • Sent by the page: the previous-run values.
  • In the lab bar: the challenge number.

Governing relationships

A few physics words first:

  • Mass: how much stuff an object is made of, in kilograms.
  • Volume: how much space it takes up, in cubic metres (m³).
  • Density: how heavy each bit of it is: ρ = mass ÷ volume, in kg/m³. The ship's volume includes the air inside its hull.
  • Buoyancy: the push up from the liquid an object pushes aside. It equals the weight of that liquid (Archimedes' principle).
  • Gravity (g): how hard a world pulls. Earth 9.80665 m/s², the Moon 1.62 m/s², Mars 3.73 m/s².

Floats or sinks. An object floats when its density is less than the liquid's, ρ < ρ_l. Its total weight does not decide it.

How deep it sits. A floating object sinks in until the liquid it pushes aside weighs as much as it does. So the share of its volume under the surface is

share under = ρ / ρ_l

A sinking object is fully under. Gravity appears on both sides and cancels, so the depth is the same on the Moon as on Earth.

The waterline. For a block with straight sides, the liquid comes up the same share of its height. For the apple, a ball, it does not: a ball is wider in the middle. With s the share under, the liquid comes up a share x of its height, the exact root of s = x²(3 - 2x):

x = 0.5 + sin(arcsin(2s - 1) / 3)

Forces. Weight W = m × g. The push up when fully under is ρ_l × V × g. At rest, a floater's push up equals its weight; a sinker on the floor gets the full push up, and the floor carries the rest. If the object is held fully under and let go, the net force is ρ_l × V × g - m × g: up if it floats, down if it sinks.

Settling (illustrative). A floater is let go with its bottom at the surface and eases down to its final depth D as D × (1 - (1 + ωt) e^(-ωt)), where ω = √(ρ_l × g × A / m) and A is its area at the waterline. The time to settle is the time to come within 1% of D. Real floaters bob up and down a little first.

Sinking (illustrative). A sinker drops through the 0.30 m deep tank with the buoyancy-reduced pull g × (ρ - ρ_l) / ρ, with no drag. Real liquids slow it, honey a lot, so no time is reported for a sinker.

Calculation sequence

  1. Check every input (see Validation and status logic).
  2. If a challenge is loaded, use the values the challenge fixes.
  3. Look up the object's mass, shape and size, the liquid's density and the world's gravity.
  4. Work out the volume and the density, compare it with the liquid's, and decide whether the object floats. A density within 1% of the liquid's is flagged as only just.
  5. Work out the share under the surface, the waterline and the forces.
  6. Work out the settling time of a floater, or the drop to the floor of a sinker, and build a film of 121 moments that runs a quarter longer than the settling or the drop.
  7. Compare your guess with what happened.
  8. See what you changed since your last run, and choose the Why? sentence.
  9. Check any challenge.

Outputs and interpretation

  • What happened and Share under the surface: Floats or Sinks (with only just when it is close), and the share of the object's volume under the surface (%).
  • Your guess: whether floats or sinks was right. If it floats and you dragged a waterline, it is spot on within 5 percentage points of the real waterline, close within 15 (and whether it floats higher or deeper than you guessed), and not quite otherwise.
  • Density: object and Density: liquid: the two numbers that decide it, side by side.
  • Why?: one sentence. If you changed exactly one thing since your last run (the object, the liquid or the world), it says what that change did. If you changed more than one thing, it asks you to change one thing at a time. Otherwise it explains the run on its own: the ship's hull with its air, mercury holding up stone and steel, only just floating or sinking, or why it floats or sinks.
  • How we got this: the equations above, with this run's numbers put in, one step per line.
  • More results: the waterline (% of the height), the mass, the weight, the push up at rest and the net force if held under and let go.

On the canvas the dotted waterline you dragged stays in place while the object settles at its real depth or drops to the floor, so you can compare them.

Challenges

Each challenge scores 100 when it is met and 0 when it is not.

  1. Steel ship, steel bolt. Both are steel: the ship weighs 3.0 kg and the bolt 79 g. Which one sinks in water on Earth? Choose the ship, the bolt, both or neither, then lock it in. It is met when your choice is right. Neither one moves until you lock it in.
  2. Make steel float. The steel bolt sinks in water. Change the liquid (and the world, if you like) until it floats. It is met when the bolt floats.
  3. An iceberg on the Moon. An ice block in sea water on the Moon. Guess floats or sinks and drag the waterline, then lock it in. It is met when you guess that it floats and your waterline is within 5 percentage points of the real one.
  4. The mystery block. A 10 cm cube with a hidden density, one of twelve values from 380 to 1,330 kg/m³, chosen by the mystery block number. Dip it in different liquids, read how far up its side the liquid comes on its 1 cm marks, and work out its density from share under = density ÷ liquid density. It is met when your guess is within 5% of the true density. Until then the block's density, mass, shares, forces and settling time stay hidden; the film runs for a fixed 2.0 s and shows the depth to the nearest millimetre. A wrong answer does not say whether it was too high or too low.

The big idea. Heavy things do not always sink, and light things do not always float. What counts is how heavy each bit of an object is, its density, compared with the liquid's. A steel ship floats because its hull, air included, is less dense than water; a small steel bolt sinks because solid steel is about eight times denser than water. The share under the surface is the object's density divided by the liquid's, and gravity does not change it.

Validation and status logic

The model checks the inputs in this order and reports the first problem it finds:

  1. The object is one of the six on the shelf.
  2. The liquid is one of the five jugs.
  3. The world is Earth, Moon or Mars.
  4. The units are Metric or Imperial.
  5. The challenge number is a whole number from 0 to 4, each guess is one of its choices, the waterline guess is empty or from 0 to 100%, the density answer is empty or from 0 to 3,000 kg/m³, and the mystery block number is a whole number from 0 to 999.
  6. If all of these pass but the object's density is within 1% of the liquid's, the status reads CHECK: it only just floats or only just sinks, and a small change, such as warmer liquid, could flip the result. Every result is still worked out. On the shelf this happens only for the ice block in cooking oil.

Otherwise the status is OK. A previous-run value that is not one of the choices counts as no previous run; it never makes the status NOT VALID.

Assumptions and limitations

  • Air is ignored; the only fluid is the liquid in the tank. The liquid is still.
  • Each object is a straight-sided block or a ball, stays upright and soaks up nothing. The ship does not tip.
  • The liquid densities are typical room-temperature values. Honey varies with its water content, and every liquid gets a little less dense as it warms.
  • The settling and sinking films are illustrative: settling has no bobbing, and sinking has no drag.

Restrictions and non-computing states

  • When an input fails a check, the status reads NOT VALID with the reason, and every result is empty except the version lines and the challenge block, which reads No challenge selected, or NOT MET with the goal and a score of 0.
  • In free play and challenge 3, every run result stays empty until you lock in your guess. Only the setup is shown: the object's mass, the liquid's density, and the object held at the surface.
  • In challenge 1, both objects stay at the surface until you lock in your choice, and the single-object results are not used.
  • A sinking object has no time to settle.
  • The Why? sentence is shown in free play only; in the challenges the challenge feedback explains instead.
  • The Imperial setting changes the densities, the mass and the forces only. Shares, the waterline, times and the film stay the same.

Errors and warnings

The status explains each problem in plain words. The wording may change; the checks do not.

  • NOT VALID, object: the object is not one of the six on the shelf.
  • NOT VALID, liquid: the liquid is not one of Water, Sea water, Cooking oil, Honey or Mercury.
  • NOT VALID, world: the world is not Earth, Moon or Mars.
  • NOT VALID, units: the units are not Metric or Imperial.
  • NOT VALID, challenge or guess: the challenge number is not a whole number from 0 to 4, a guess is not one of its choices, the waterline guess is outside 0 to 100%, the density answer is outside 0 to 3,000 kg/m³, or the mystery block number is not a whole number from 0 to 999.
  • CHECK, only just: the object's density is within 1% of the liquid's, so it only just floats or only just sinks. The results are still shown.

If the page cannot reach the model at all, it says so separately. That is a connection problem, not a result of the model.

References

This laboratory is an educational model of floating and sinking. An object's density is its mass divided by its volume, and it floats when that density is less than the liquid's. By Archimedes' principle the push up equals the weight of the liquid pushed aside, so a floating object sinks in until that weight matches its own, and the share of it under the surface is its density divided by the liquid's. For a ball the lab finds the waterline from the exact root of the cubic for the volume of a slice of a sphere. The settling and sinking films are simple illustrative models.

Sources and further reading

  • Density as mass per unit volume, with typical densities of water, sea water, ice, steel and mercury: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 11.2, Density. OpenStax
  • Archimedes' principle, floating and sinking by density, and the fraction of a floating object under the surface: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 11.7, Archimedes' Principle. OpenStax
  • The buoyant force equals the weight of the fluid displaced: R. Nave, HyperPhysics, Buoyancy, Georgia State University. HyperPhysics
  • The density of water, how it changes with temperature, and why ice floats with about a tenth above the surface: U.S. Geological Survey, Water Density, Water Science School. USGS
  • Surface gravity of the Moon and of Mars: NASA Space Science Data Coordinated Archive, Moon Fact Sheet and Mars Fact Sheet, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. NASA Moon Fact Sheet, NASA Mars Fact Sheet

No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.

This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; the liquid densities are typical room-temperature values, and a real object can bob, tip or soak up liquid.

Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.

Results are informational and not professional advice. See our Terms of Use. Powered by SpreadsheetWeb · About · Privacy · Terms