Physics Lab 101

Push and Friction: Does Motion Need a Push?

Does a moving object need a constant push to keep going? Push a crate along a 10 m floor of ice, wood, carpet or a rubber mat on Earth, the Moon, Mars or in a vacuum, place your guess where you think it will stop, and turn friction on or off. Watch the run, see when and where the crate stops with the equations behind it, and read one sentence on why; three short challenges test the idea. For learning that a push starts and speeds up motion, and friction slows it down.

Last updated

Calculator overview

Inputs and outputs

This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.

Inputs

Push force (required)
About this input

The steady level push on the crate, 0 to 300 N. Set by dragging the head of the push arrow on the canvas; exact entry in its popover.

Unit N Default 120 Range 0 to 300
Push time (required)
About this input

How long the push lasts from the start of the run, 0.5 to 5 s. Set with the end handle of the push bar on the timeline under the floor.

Unit s Default 1 Range 0.5 to 5
Your guess: where the crate will stop
When omitted Blank
About this input

Play only: where you think the crate will stop, in m from the start line, 0 to 10 (10 means it will not stop on this floor). Blank until you lock in your guess; the run is shown once you do.

Unit m Default Not set Range 0 to 10
World (required)
About this input

The world the floor is on: Earth, Moon, Mars or Vacuum (Earth gravity with no air). Gravity sets how hard the crate presses on the floor. Chosen with the world chips.

Default Earth Allowed Earth, Moon, Mars, Vacuum
Floor surface (required)
About this input

The floor under the crate: ice, wood, carpet or a rubber mat, each with a typical grip to start (static friction coefficient) and grip while sliding (kinetic friction coefficient). Chosen with the floor swatches on the canvas.

Default Wood Allowed Ice, Wood, Carpet, Rubber mat
Crate mass (required)
About this input

The mass of the crate, 5 to 100 kg. Chosen on the canvas by clicking a crate on the shelf (5, 10, 20, 40 or 80 kg); any value in the range by exact entry in its popover.

Unit kg Default 20 Range 5 to 100
Challenge number (required)
About this input

Selects the level: 0 for Play, 1 to 3 for a challenge, which fixes the settings except the ones it leaves to you.

Default 0 Range 0 to 3
Units (required)
About this input

Metric or Imperial: the units of the result cards (ft, ft/s and lbf in Imperial). The challenges, the animation and the canvas labels stay metric. The units chips on the stage.

Default Metric Allowed Metric, Imperial
Friction (required)
About this input

On or Off. Off sets both friction coefficients to 0: any push starts the crate, and after the push it keeps sliding at the same speed. The friction switch on the floor.

Default On Allowed On, Off
Your guess: which world needs the smaller push (required)
About this input

Challenge 3 only: which world needs the smaller push to start the crate: Earth, Moon or Same on both. It starts at Not yet predicted; the results appear once you lock in your guess.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Earth, Moon, Same on both

Outputs

The run, frame by frame: time, position, speed, push force and friction force (negative points back)
About this output

One row per frame n = 0 to 150 at equal time steps over the run: the time, the position, the speed, the push force and the friction force (negative points back). While a prediction is awaited only row 0 shows, without its friction cell; every cell is blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Push needed to start it on Earth
About this output

Challenge 3: the push needed to start this crate on Earth, in N, or lbf in Imperial. Blank outside challenge 3, until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit N
Push needed to start it on the Moon
About this output

Challenge 3: the push needed to start this crate on the Moon, in N, or lbf in Imperial. Blank outside challenge 3, until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit N
Formula module versions
About this output

The version of each part of the lab's calculation.

No unit declared
Your guess
About this output

Play: how close your guess was, in words: Spot on (within 0.25 m of where the crate ends up), Close (within 1 m) or Far off, each with one sentence saying how far off your guess was, to 2 decimals in m (ft with Imperial units), from where the crate stopped, from where it stayed, or from the end of the floor it reached; or Not tested when the crate reached the end of the floor while still pushed. Blank outside Play, while your guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Speed when the push stopped
About this output

The speed of the crate when the push stopped, in m/s, or ft/s in Imperial (0 when it did not move). Blank when it reached the end of the floor while still pushed, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m/s
When it stopped
About this output

When the crate stopped, in s from the start of the push. Blank when it did not move or reached the end of the floor, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit s
Why?
About this output

One plain sentence that explains the run (the Why? card), chosen from what happened; a prompt while a guess is awaited. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
How we got this
About this output

How we got this: the working behind the results, one step per line. Each line names the step, gives its equation, the same equation with this run's numbers, and the result. The working is in SI units (kg, N, m, s); with Imperial units each result also gives its Imperial value in brackets. Until every input is valid, and while a guess is awaited, it shows one neutral sentence instead; in challenge 1 the value of the push needed to start the crate is not shown until the challenge is met (the line gives its equation, so it can be worked out from the grip, the mass and gravity).

No unit declared
Grip to start (static coefficient)
About this output

The grip to start (static friction coefficient) of the floor used; 0 with friction off. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Push needed to start it (static friction)
About this output

The push needed to start the crate: the most static friction the floor can give (the grip to start times the crate's weight), in N, or lbf in Imperial. Shown in challenge 2, in challenge 1 once met and in challenge 3 once you have guessed; blank in Play and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit N
Where it stopped
About this output

Where the crate stopped, in m from the start line, or ft in Imperial (0 when it did not move). Blank when it reached the end of the floor, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Challenge 1: the push that started it
About this output

Challenge 1: the push that started the crate, the value scored, in N, or lbf in Imperial. Blank outside challenge 1, when the crate did not move and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit N
Challenge result
About this output

No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.

No unit declared
Reached the end of the floor at
About this output

When the crate reached the end of the 10 m floor, in s. Blank unless it reaches the end, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit s
Challenge feedback
About this output

Feedback on the selected challenge: the met text or the not-met hint; in challenge 3 a neutral prompt until you guess (blank in Play).

No unit declared
Challenge goal
About this output

The goal of the selected challenge (blank in Play).

No unit declared
Challenge 2: where the crate stopped
About this output

Challenge 2: where the crate stopped, the value scored, in m, or ft in Imperial. Blank outside challenge 2, when the crate reached the end of the floor and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Gravity of the world
About this output

The gravity of the world used, in m/s2. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m/s2
Model Status
About this output

NOT VALID with the reason when an input cannot be used; otherwise OK.

No unit declared
Model version
About this output

The version of this lab.

No unit declared
Challenge target centre
About this output

Challenge 2: the centre of the target on the floor, in m. Blank outside challenge 2 and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Challenge target half-width
About this output

Challenge 2: the half-width of the target, in m. Blank outside challenge 2 and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
Grip while sliding (kinetic coefficient)
About this output

The grip while sliding (kinetic friction coefficient) of the floor used; 0 with friction off. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
This page is provided by LogicCommons for informational purposes only. Results are analysis outputs computed from the inputs you supply and are not professional advice. Verify all inputs and results independently.

LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.

Methodology

Purpose and model boundary

Many people think a moving object needs a constant push to keep going, so when the push stops, it stops. This lab tests that idea. You push a crate along a 10 m floor of ice, wood, carpet or a rubber mat, on Earth, the Moon, Mars or in a vacuum (a space with no air), and you can switch friction on or off. Before the run you make your guess: where will the crate stop? Then the lab shows what really happens.

The lab is for learning that a push starts a crate moving and speeds it up, and that friction is what slows it down. It uses typical values for each floor. It does not predict a real crate: real floors are uneven, and their grip changes with dirt, wear and moisture.

The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what it sends back: the crate on the floor, the push and friction arrows, the speed chart and the target. The page works out no speed, distance or force itself.

Inputs and units

Input Meaning and unit
Crate mass How much stuff the crate is made of, from 5 to 100 kg (default 20 kg). The shelf offers 5, 10, 20, 40 and 80 kg crates; any value in the range can be typed.
Floor surface Ice, Wood, Carpet or Rubber mat (default Wood).
Push force The steady push on the crate, from 0 to 300 N (newtons, default 120 N).
Push time How long the push lasts from the start, from 0.5 to 5 s (default 1 s).
World Earth, Moon, Mars or Vacuum (default Earth).
Friction On or Off (default On).
Your guess: where the crate will stop Free play only: a distance from the start line, from 0 to 10 m. 10 m means it will not stop on this floor. It starts empty.
Your guess: which world needs the smaller push Challenge 3 only: Earth, Moon or Same on both. It starts as Not yet predicted.
Units Metric or Imperial (default Metric). Imperial shows the result cards in feet, feet per second and pounds of force.
Challenge number 0 for free play, or 1 to 3 to load a challenge (default 0).

Where each input is set:

  • On the canvas only: everything. You click a crate on the shelf, click a floor swatch, drag the head of the push arrow, drag the end of the push bar on the timeline, tap a world, flip the friction switch, drag your guess onto the floor and press Lock in my guess. The units are two small buttons. Every handle also opens a small box for typing an exact value. The lab has no input panel.
  • In the lab bar: the challenge number.

Governing relationships

A few physics words first:

  • Force: a push or a pull, measured in newtons (N).
  • Weight: how hard the crate presses down on the floor: W = m × g, where m is the mass and g the pull of gravity. Earth 9.80665 m/s², the Moon 1.62 m/s², Mars 3.73 m/s². A vacuum on Earth has Earth's gravity.
  • Static friction: the grip that holds a resting crate still. It can grow up to a limit, then the crate starts to slide. The limit is F_s = μ_s × W, where μ_s is the floor's grip to start.
  • Kinetic friction: the grip while the crate slides: F_k = μ_k × W, where μ_k is the grip while sliding. It is always a little smaller than the limit of static friction.
Floor Grip to start, μ_s Grip while sliding, μ_k
Ice 0.10 0.05
Wood 0.40 0.30
Carpet 0.55 0.45
Rubber mat 0.70 0.60

With friction Off, both are 0.

Does it start? The crate moves only if the push F is bigger than F_s. A push exactly at the limit is still held by static friction.

During the push (time T). The force left over is F - F_k, so the crate speeds up at a = (F - F_k) / m (Newton's second law). At the end of the push its speed is v = a × T, and it has moved a × T² / 2.

After the push. Only friction acts. It slows the crate at μ_k × g. The crate slides on a further v² / (2 μ_k g) and stops after another v / (μ_k g) seconds. With friction Off nothing slows it: it keeps its speed to the end of the floor.

Calculation sequence

  1. Check every input (see Validation and status logic).
  2. If a challenge is loaded, use the values the challenge fixes.
  3. Look up the floor's two grips (0 with friction Off) and the world's gravity.
  4. Work out the weight and the static friction limit, and decide whether the crate starts.
  5. Work out the speed and distance at the end of the push, then where and when the crate stops, or when it reaches the end of the 10 m floor.
  6. Build a film of 151 moments, from the start to the stop plus a little more (about a quarter of the run again), or to the end of the floor, and never longer than 15 s. Each moment gives the position, the speed, the push force and the friction force.
  7. Compare your guess with where the crate really ended up: at 0 if it never moved, at 10 m if it reached the end, otherwise where it stopped.
  8. Choose the sentence that explains the run, then check any challenge.

Outputs and interpretation

  • Speed when the push stopped (m/s), Where it stopped (m from the start line) and When it stopped (s). If the crate reaches the end of the floor, Reached the end of the floor at (s) takes the place of the stop results.
  • Your guess: Spot on within 0.25 m of where the crate ended up, Close within 1 m, Far off otherwise. If the crate reached the end of the floor while you were still pushing, your guess is not tested, because you never saw what happens after the push.
  • Why?: one sentence on why it happened: nothing pushed it; the push was below the static friction limit; with no friction it kept its speed; it reached the end while still pushed; it was still sliding at the end; you guessed where the push stopped, but it kept sliding; it slid only a little (under 0.25 m) on a grippy floor; it still stopped in a vacuum; or, most often, no push is needed to keep moving and friction slowed it.
  • How we got this: the equations above, with this run's numbers put in, one step per line.
  • Other results: the two grips used and the world's gravity. In the challenges, the push needed to start the crate (the static friction limit) is also shown, and in challenge 3 the push needed to start it on Earth and on the Moon, side by side.

On the canvas the push arrow and the friction arrow are drawn to the same scale. While the crate is stuck, friction matches the push. While it speeds up, friction is shorter than the push. After the push, friction is the only arrow left. The speed chart shows the speed rising during the push and falling after it.

Challenges

  1. Start it moving. A 40 kg crate on wood, on Earth, with friction on. Find the smallest push that starts it. It is met when the crate moves and your push is no more than 3% above the static friction limit. The push needed stays hidden until you meet it.
  2. Stop on the target. A 20 kg crate on wood, on Earth. Choose the push so the crate stops inside the target, which is centred 6 m from the start and reaches 0.15 m either side. It is met when the crate stops inside it.
  3. Moon or Earth. A 40 kg crate on wood. Make your guess first: Earth, the Moon, or the same on both. Then test it by changing the push and the world. It is met when your guess is the Moon. Nothing is shown until you lock in your guess.

The big idea. A push is needed to start a crate and to speed it up, not to keep it moving. When the push stops, friction is what slows the crate down. Take friction away and it keeps going. Friction depends on how hard the crate presses on the floor, so on the Moon, where it presses down about six times less, a much smaller push starts the same crate.

Validation and status logic

The model checks the inputs in this order and reports the first problem it finds:

  1. The crate mass is from 5 to 100 kg.
  2. The floor is one of the four surfaces.
  3. The push force is from 0 to 300 N.
  4. The push time is from 0.5 to 5 s.
  5. The world is one of the four worlds.
  6. The friction switch is On or Off.
  7. The units are Metric or Imperial.
  8. The challenge number is a whole number from 0 to 3, and each guess is empty or allowed: a stop guess from 0 to 10 m, and a world guess that is one of its choices.

If all pass, the status is OK.

Assumptions and limitations

  • The grips are typical values for a wooden crate, not measured ones. Real floors vary a lot.
  • The push is level and steady, and it stops at once.
  • Friction does not depend on how fast the crate slides or on how big its base is.
  • There is no air drag. Air hardly slows a sliding crate, which is why a vacuum gives the same result as Earth.
  • The crate slides and never tips over. The floor ends at 10 m.

Restrictions and non-computing states

  • When an input fails a check, the status reads NOT VALID with the reason, and every result is empty except the version lines and the challenge block, which reads No challenge selected, or NOT MET with the goal.
  • In free play, every result stays empty until you lock in your guess. The film shows only the crate at the start line with the push arrow.
  • In challenge 3, nothing is shown until you make your world guess.
  • When the crate reaches the end of the floor, where and when it stopped are empty. When it reaches the end while still pushed, the speed when the push stopped is empty too.
  • When the crate does not move, its speed and distance are 0.
  • The Imperial setting changes the result cards only. Times, grips, gravity, your guess and the film stay metric.

Errors and warnings

The status explains each problem in plain words. The wording may change; the checks do not.

  • NOT VALID, crate mass: the mass is empty, not a number, or outside 5 to 100 kg.
  • NOT VALID, floor: the floor is not one of Ice, Wood, Carpet or Rubber mat.
  • NOT VALID, push force: the push is empty, not a number, or outside 0 to 300 N.
  • NOT VALID, push time: the push time is empty, not a number, or outside 0.5 to 5 s.
  • NOT VALID, world: the world is not one of Earth, Moon, Mars or Vacuum.
  • NOT VALID, friction switch: the switch is not On or Off.
  • NOT VALID, units: the units are not Metric or Imperial.
  • NOT VALID, challenge or guess: the challenge number is not a whole number from 0 to 3, or a guess is not one of the allowed values.

If the page cannot reach the model at all, it says so separately. That is a connection problem, not a result of the model.

References

This laboratory is an educational model of a crate pushed along a floor. A resting crate is held by static friction up to a limit equal to the floor's grip to start times the crate's weight, so it moves only when the push is bigger than that limit. While it slides, kinetic friction acts against it with the grip while sliding times its weight. Newton's second law gives the speeding up during the push and the slowing down after it, and the standard equations for constant acceleration give the speeds, distances and times. With no friction, Newton's first law says the crate keeps its speed.

Sources and further reading

  • A moving object keeps moving at constant velocity unless a net force acts, and friction is what slows a sliding object: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 4.2, Newton's First Law of Motion: Inertia. OpenStax
  • Acceleration equals the net force divided by the mass: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 4.3, Newton's Second Law of Motion: Concept of a System. OpenStax
  • Static and kinetic friction, their coefficients, and why kinetic friction is smaller: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 5.1, Friction. OpenStax
  • Friction proportional to the force pressing the surfaces together, with static and kinetic coefficients: R. Nave, HyperPhysics, Friction, Georgia State University. HyperPhysics
  • Speed, distance and time under constant acceleration: OpenStax, College Physics 2e, Rice University, section 2.5, Motion Equations for Constant Acceleration in One Dimension. OpenStax

No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.

This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; the floor grips are typical values, and a real floor's grip changes with dirt, wear and moisture.

Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.

Results are informational and not professional advice. See our Terms of Use. Powered by SpreadsheetWeb · About · Privacy · Terms