Physics Lab 101

Ramp Race: Does the Steeper Ramp Always Win by a Lot?

Does a steeper ramp always win, and by a lot? Race a sliding block, a rolling ball or a rolling hoop down two ramps side by side, each 5 to 60 degrees steep and 0.5 to 5 m long, on Earth, the Moon or Mars. Closed-form speed-ups for sliding with friction and for rolling give each time to the bottom, the speed there, how far down the slower racer was when the winner finished and a 121-frame film of the race. Pick the winner and place your guess first: the model scores it, a Why? sentence and the How we got this working explain each race, and three challenges are scored for you. For learning that twice as steep is nowhere near twice as fast, and that the racer matters as much as the slope.

Last updated

Calculator overview

Inputs and outputs

This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.

Inputs

Ramp B length (required)
About this input

The length of ramp B along the slope, 0.5 to 5 m. Set by dragging the top end of the ramp along the slope; exact entry in its popover.

Unit m Default 2 Range 0.5 to 5
Ramp A length (required)
About this input

The length of ramp A along the slope, 0.5 to 5 m. Set by dragging the top end of the ramp along the slope; exact entry in its popover.

Unit m Default 2 Range 0.5 to 5
Your guess: how far down the other racer will be
When omitted Blank
About this input

Your guess: where you think the other racer will be when the winner finishes, as a % of the way down its own ramp (0 the top, 100 the bottom). Blank until you make your guess. Used in Play and in challenge 1.

Unit % Default Not set Range 0 to 100
World (required)
About this input

The world both ramps are on: Earth, Moon or Mars. Gravity sets how fast everything goes, but not who wins or by what share. Chosen with the world chips.

Default Earth Allowed Earth, Moon, Mars
Your pick: who reaches the bottom first (required)
About this input

Your pick before the race: Ramp A, Ramp B or Together. It starts at Not yet predicted; the race appears once you lock in your guess. Used in Play and in challenges 1 and 2.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Ramp A, Ramp B, Together
Ramp B angle (required)
About this input

The slope of ramp B, 5 to 60 degrees. Set on the canvas by dragging the angle grip at the foot of the ramp; any decimal in the range by exact entry in its popover.

Unit deg Default 40 Range 5 to 60
Units (required)
About this input

Metric or Imperial: the units of the distance and speed cards (ft and ft/s in Imperial). Times, angles, percentages, the film and the canvas labels stay metric. The units chips on the stage.

Default Metric Allowed Metric, Imperial
Challenge number (required)
About this input

Selects the level: 0 for Play, 1 to 3 for a challenge, which fixes the settings except the ones it leaves to you.

Default 0 Range 0 to 3
Ramp A racer (required)
About this input

The racer on ramp A: Block (slides, held back by friction), Ball (a solid ball that rolls) or Hoop (a thin hoop that rolls). Chosen by clicking a racer on the lane's shelf.

Default Ball Allowed Block, Ball, Hoop
Ramp A angle (required)
About this input

The slope of ramp A, 5 to 60 degrees. Set on the canvas by dragging the angle grip at the foot of the ramp; any decimal in the range by exact entry in its popover.

Unit deg Default 20 Range 5 to 60
Ramp B racer (required)
About this input

The racer on ramp B: Block, Ball or Hoop, chosen on the lane's shelf.

Default Ball Allowed Block, Ball, Hoop

Outputs

The race, frame by frame: time, then each racer's distance down its ramp, speed and spin
About this output

The race frame by frame: 121 rows of time, then for each ramp the racer's distance down the ramp (m), speed (m/s) and spin (degrees; 0 for a block, which slides). Row 80 is the moment the winner finishes; rows 80 to 120 run on to the slower finish. Row 0 is shown before the start; the rest appears once your guess is locked in.

No unit declared
Race result
About this output

Who reached the bottom first, in words: ramp A, ramp B, together (within 1%), only one ramp (the other block never started) or neither. Blank while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Your guess
About this output

Your guess, scored in words: the right winner or not, and how close your guess was (spot on within 5% of the way down, close within 15%, or whether the lead was smaller or bigger than you guessed). Blank in challenges 2 and 3, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
Formula module versions
About this output

The formula modules the model is built from, with their versions.

No unit declared
Your guess was off by
About this output

How far your guess was from where the other racer really was, in % of the way down its ramp. Shown only when your pick was right and the race was not a tie.

Unit %
Why?
About this output

One plain sentence that explains the race (the Why? card), chosen by the model from the case; a prompt while a guess is awaited. Blank when the inputs are not valid.

No unit declared
How we got this
About this output

The How we got this text: the equations behind each racer's speed-up, time and speed at the bottom and behind the gap at the finish, then the same equations with this race's numbers, one step per line. The working is in SI units; in Imperial each result also gives its Imperial value in brackets. A short neutral line instead while the inputs are not valid or while a guess is awaited.

No unit declared
The other racer was this far down
About this output

How far down its own ramp the other racer was when the winner finished, in % (100 when they finish together, 0 when it never started). Blank when neither racer moves, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit %
Ramp A: time to the bottom
About this output

The time ramp A's racer takes to reach the bottom, in s. Blank when it never starts (a block on a gentle ramp), while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit s
Ramp B: time to the bottom
About this output

The time ramp B's racer takes to reach the bottom, in s. Blank when it never starts, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit s
Distance it still had to go
About this output

The distance the other racer still had to go when the winner finished, in m, or ft in Imperial. Blank when they finish together or neither moves, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m
It arrived later by
About this output

How much later the other racer reached the bottom, in s. Blank when they finish together or the other racer never starts, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit s
Challenge result
About this output

No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.

No unit declared
Challenge feedback
About this output

Feedback on the selected challenge: the met text or a hint; a neutral prompt while a guess is awaited (blank in Play).

No unit declared
Challenge goal
About this output

The goal of the selected challenge (blank in Play).

No unit declared
Model Status
About this output

NOT VALID with the reason when an input cannot be used; CHECK when a hoop is on a ramp steeper than 45 degrees (a real hoop tends to slide instead of roll there; the times shown are for a hoop that rolls all the way down); otherwise OK.

No unit declared
Model version
About this output

The model version.

No unit declared
Ramp B: speed at the bottom
About this output

The speed of ramp B's racer at the bottom, in m/s, or ft/s in Imperial. Blank when it never starts, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m/s
The slower racer took this much longer
About this output

How much longer the slower racer took, as a % of the winner's time. Blank unless both racers move, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit %
Ramp A: speed at the bottom
About this output

The speed of ramp A's racer at the bottom, in m/s, or ft/s in Imperial. Blank when it never starts, while a guess is awaited and when the inputs are not valid.

Unit m/s
This page is provided by LogicCommons for informational purposes only. Results are analysis outputs computed from the inputs you supply and are not professional advice. Verify all inputs and results independently.

LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.

Methodology

Purpose and model boundary

Many people think a steeper ramp always wins a race, and wins by a lot: twice as steep should mean about twice as fast. This lab tests that idea. Two ramps stand side by side. On each you choose a racer (a sliding block, a rolling ball or a rolling hoop), the slope and the length, and you can move the race to the Moon or Mars. You make your guess first, and then the lab runs the race and shows what really happens.

For each race the model works out each racer's speed-up, its time to the bottom and its speed there, who wins, and how far down its own ramp the other racer was when the winner finished. Three challenges follow, ending with one where you make a hoop and a ball finish together.

The lab is for learning two ideas: a steeper ramp wins by much less than people expect, and the kind of racer matters as much as the slope. It is not a model of a real race. There is no air, the ramps are perfectly straight, and every racer starts from rest at the top.

The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what it sends back: where each racer is, how fast it goes and how far it has turned at each moment of the race. The page works out no speed-up, time or speed itself.

Inputs and units

Input Meaning and unit
Ramp A angle, Ramp B angle How steep each ramp is: 5° to 60°. Defaults: ramp A 20°, ramp B 40°.
Ramp A length, Ramp B length How long each ramp is, measured along the slope: 0.5 to 5 m. Default 2 m for both.
Ramp A racer, Ramp B racer Block (slides, held back by friction), Ball (a solid ball that rolls) or Hoop (a thin hoop that rolls). Default Ball for both.
World Earth, the Moon or Mars (default Earth). Both ramps are on the same world.
Units Metric or Imperial (default Metric). It changes only how distances and speeds are shown.
Your guess: who reaches the bottom first Not yet predicted (the start), Ramp A, Ramp B or Together. Used in Play and challenges 1 and 2.
Your guess: how far down the other racer will be Where you think the other racer will be when the winner finishes, as a percentage of the way down its own ramp: 0% is the top and 100% the bottom. Blank until you place it. Used in Play and challenge 1. Picking Together sets it to 100%, and the model then does not use it.
Challenge number 0 for Play, or 1 to 3 for a challenge (default 0).

Where each input is set:

  • On the canvas: every input. There is no input panel. Drag the angle grip at the foot of a ramp to change its slope, and drag the top end of a ramp to change its length. Click a racer on each lane's shelf. Use the world chips and the units chips. Pick who you think will win with the three buttons, drag the dotted marker along the other ramp to where you think that racer will be, then press Lock in my guess. The challenge picker chooses Play or a challenge.
  • On the canvas, angles move in steps of 1° and lengths in steps of 0.1 m; exact values can be typed in each grip's box.

Fixed values: gravity g is 9.80665 m/s² on Earth (shown as 9.81), 1.62 m/s² on the Moon and 3.73 m/s² on Mars. The block's friction coefficient is 0.20. In Imperial units, distances are shown in feet (1 ft = 0.3048 m) and speeds in ft/s. Times, angles and percentages do not change.

Governing relationships

Speed-up (acceleration). Acceleration is how quickly something speeds up, in metres per second each second (m/s²). On a slope of angle θ, gravity pulls a racer along the slope with g × sin θ for every kilogram. The sine of the angle grows more slowly than the angle itself: sin 40° is about 1.88 times sin 20°, not 2 times.

A sliding block. Friction, the grip between the block and the ramp, holds part of the pull back. With the friction coefficient μ = 0.20:

a = g × (sin θ - μ × cos θ)

If this comes out zero or less, friction wins and the block never starts. That happens on slopes below about 11.3°.

A rolling ball or hoop. A rolling racer has no sliding friction, but it spends part of its energy on spinning. How much depends on its spin factor k, which is 0.4 for a solid ball and 1 for a thin hoop (k is the racer's moment of inertia divided by its mass times its radius squared):

a = g × sin θ ÷ (1 + k)

So a ball speeds up at 5/7 of the pull and a hoop at only 1/2 of it. The mass and size of the racer do not matter.

Time and speed. Every racer starts from rest and speeds up steadily. Its distance down the slope after a time t is d = ½ × a × t². It reaches the bottom of a ramp of length L at

t = √(2 × L ÷ a)

and its speed there is v = a × t. Because the time depends on the square root of the speed-up, twice the speed-up makes the race only about 1.41 times as fast.

Who wins and by how much. The racer with the shorter time wins. The lead is how much longer the slower racer took, as a percentage of the winner's time. If that lead is 1% or less, the race counts as Together. The share of the way down is where the other racer is when the winner finishes, d = ½ × a × t² at the winner's time, as a percentage of its own ramp length.

Why gravity sets the pace but not the margin. Every speed-up contains the same g, so on the Moon every time is longer by the same factor. The winner, the lead and the share of the way down stay exactly the same.

Calculation sequence

  1. The model checks your inputs and sets the status.
  2. In a challenge, the challenge's own values replace the locked inputs.
  3. For each ramp it works out the racer's speed-up and whether it moves at all.
  4. For each moving racer it works out the time to the bottom and the speed there.
  5. It finds the winner (or Together, within 1%), the lead, how far down the other racer was at the winner's finish, the distance it still had to go and how much later it arrived.
  6. It builds the film of the race: 121 moments. The first 81 run from the start to the winner's finish, and the rest run on until the other racer finishes. If the other racer never starts, the film runs on to 1.25 times the winner's time; if neither moves, it lasts 2 s with both at rest. Each moment gives each racer's distance down, speed and how far it has turned.
  7. It compares your guess with the result, picks a Why? sentence, writes out the working and scores any challenge.

Outputs and interpretation

  • Race result: ramp A first, ramp B first, together (within 1%), only one ramp moved (the other block never started), or neither moved.
  • The other racer was this far down: in %, from 0 at the top to 100 at the bottom; 100 when they finish together and 0 when the other racer never started.
  • Your guess: whether you picked the right winner and how close your guess of the other racer's place was: spot on (within 5 points), close (within 15 points), or whether the lead was smaller or bigger than you guessed. Your guess was off by gives the difference in percentage points, shown when your winner was right and the race was not a tie.
  • Time to the bottom for each ramp, in seconds; blank for a block that never starts.
  • Distance it still had to go, in m (ft), and It arrived later by, in seconds.
  • The slower racer took this much longer: the lead, in % of the winner's time.
  • Speed at the bottom for each ramp, in m/s (ft/s).
  • Why?: one plain sentence that explains the race.
  • How we got this: the working, one step per line, with this race's numbers.

On the canvas, both ramps share one scale so their steepness and length compare fairly. The run pauses for about a second when the winner finishes: the other racer, drawn solid, is what really happened, and the dotted marker beside it is your guess. The ball's stripe and the hoop's spokes turn as they roll; the block slides without turning.

Challenges

Each challenge is scored MET or NOT MET, with no points, and gives a hint while it is not met. Every challenge is on Earth.

  1. Twice as steep. Two balls on 2 m ramps: ramp A at 15° and ramp B at 30°. Pick the winner and place your guess of where ramp A's ball will be when ramp B's ball finishes, then lock it in. It is met when you pick ramp B and your guess is within 10 percentage points of where the ball really is. Nothing is shown until you lock in.
  2. Steeper loses? A sliding block on a 24° ramp A against a rolling ball on a 20° ramp B, both 2 m long. Pick who reaches the bottom first, then lock it in. It is met when you pick ramp B. Nothing is shown until you lock in.
  3. Finish together. A hoop on ramp A races a ball on a 24°, 2 m ramp B. Change ramp A's angle or length until they finish together. It is met when both move and the lead is 1% or less. There is no guess here: the race runs each time you change ramp A.

The big idea: a steeper ramp does win, but by much less than people expect. Twice the angle gives less than twice the pull, and the time depends only on the square root of the pull. What the racer is matters just as much: a block loses some of its pull to friction, and a ball or a hoop spends some of its energy on spinning.

Validation and status logic

The status reads the first match:

  1. NOT VALID when an input is outside its allowed values, checked in this order: the racers, the angles, the lengths, the world, the units, and then the challenge number and the guesses.
  2. CHECK when a hoop is on a ramp steeper than 45°. Everything is still worked out.
  3. OK otherwise.

Assumptions and limitations

  • There is no air resistance, and the ramps are straight and smooth apart from the stated grip.
  • The block has one friction coefficient, 0.20, for both starting and sliding.
  • Balls and hoops roll without skidding. A hoop on a slope steeper than 45° would need a very grippy ramp to do that (a grip coefficient above 0.50); the lab still assumes it rolls and shows a CHECK.
  • Every racer starts from rest at the top, and both start at the same moment.
  • A lead of 1% or less counts as a tie.
  • The turning shown on the canvas uses a drawing radius of 0.08 m; it shows that a racer rolls, not its real size.

Restrictions and non-computing states

When the status is NOT VALID, every result and the film are blank, and a selected challenge reads NOT MET.

Before you lock in your guess in Play and challenges 1 and 2, every result is held back: the film shows only the start, the Why? card asks for your guess and the working stays hidden. A block that never starts has no time and no speed at the bottom.

Errors and warnings

The model's messages, in the order it checks them (first match wins):

  • NOT VALID, racers: a racer is not Block, Ball or Hoop.
  • NOT VALID, ramp angles: an angle is blank or outside 5° to 60°.
  • NOT VALID, ramp lengths: a length is blank or outside 0.5 to 5 m.
  • NOT VALID, world: the world is not Earth, the Moon or Mars.
  • NOT VALID, units: the units are not Metric or Imperial.
  • NOT VALID, challenge or guesses: the challenge number is not a whole number from 0 to 3, the winner guess is not one of its choices, or the guess of how far down is not blank or from 0% to 100%.
  • CHECK, a hoop on a very steep ramp: a hoop is on a ramp steeper than 45°; the times assume it still rolls without skidding, and every result is shown.
  • OK: the inputs are valid.

References

This laboratory is an educational model of a race down two straight ramps. A sliding block speeds up with the part of gravity along the slope minus kinetic friction, g × (sin θ - μ × cos θ). A rolling ball or hoop speeds up with g × sin θ ÷ (1 + I ÷ mr²), because part of its energy goes into spinning. Each racer starts from rest with a steady speed-up, so its time to the bottom follows from the constant-acceleration equations, and the winner, the lead and the other racer's place at the finish follow from comparing the two lanes.

Sources and further reading

  • The pull along a slope, kinetic friction on an incline and the speed-up g × (sin θ - μ × cos θ): OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 6.2, Friction, Friction and the Inclined Plane, Example 6.14. OpenStax
  • Rolling without slipping down an incline, the speed-up g × sin θ ÷ (1 + I ÷ mr²), and the static friction a rolling object needs: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 11.1, Rolling Motion, Example 11.1. OpenStax
  • The spin factor I = c × MR² (2/5 for a solid sphere, 1 for a thin cylinder) and why objects with a smaller factor roll down faster: M. Mears, Lecture 9: Rolling Motion, PHY11006 Mechanics course notes. M. Mears course notes
  • A race between a hoop and a cylinder rolling down the same incline, and why the mass and radius cancel: Georgia State University HyperPhysics, Hoop and Cylinder Motion, Department of Physics and Astronomy. HyperPhysics
  • Distance and speed under constant acceleration from rest, d = ½ × a × t² and v = a × t: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 3.4, Motion with Constant Acceleration. OpenStax

No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.

This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; real racers meet air resistance, bumpy ramps and grip that changes once they move, so real races differ a little.

Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.

Results are informational and not professional advice. See our Terms of Use. Powered by SpreadsheetWeb · About · Privacy · Terms