Calculator overview
Inputs and outputs
This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.
Inputs
- Your guess: the box's mass
-
When omitted Blank
Unit kg Default Not set Range 0 to 100
About this input
Challenge 3 only: your answer for the mystery box's mass, 0 to 100 kg, picked on the box's scale. Blank until you pick one; an answer within 0.6 kg of the box's mass meets the challenge. The plank is balanced from the start, so the box's mass follows from load A's: mass x distance is the same on both sides.
- Mystery box number (required)
-
Default 0 Range 0 to 999
About this input
Challenge 3 only: the number of the mystery box, a whole number from 0 to 999, which picks its hidden mass; the 30 kg child is then seated where it balances the box. The New box button steps it.
- Load B position (required)
-
Unit m Default 3.6 Range 0.1 to 3.9
About this input
Where load B sits along the plank, 0.10 to 3.90 m from its left end. Set by dragging load B on the canvas.
- World (required)
-
Default Earth Allowed Earth, Moon, Mars
About this input
Where the seesaw stands: Earth, the Moon or Mars. Gravity changes how fast it tips, not which way. Chosen with the world chips on the canvas.
- Your guess: which way it tips (required)
-
Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, Left side down, Right side down, Balanced
About this input
Play and challenge 4: your guess, Left side down, Right side down or Balanced, picked with the buttons above the scene and then locked in. It starts as Not yet predicted; the results stay hidden until you lock in a guess. Changing the setup clears it.
- Pivot position (required)
-
Unit m Default 2 Range 1 to 3
About this input
Where the pivot sits along the 4 m plank, 1.00 to 3.00 m from its left end. Set by dragging the pivot triangle under the plank on the canvas; the plank and its loads stay put while the support slides.
- Units shown (required)
-
Default Metric Allowed Metric, Imperial
About this input
Metric or Imperial: the turning effects in N m or lbf ft, the balance spot in m or ft and the box's mass in kg or lb. Everything is computed in metric; angles and times do not change. Chosen with the units chips on the canvas; it never clears your guess.
- Challenge number (required)
-
Default 0 Range 0 to 4
About this input
0 for Play; 1 to 4 load a challenge (1: lift the grown-up; 2: where must the small child sit?; 3: the mystery box; 4: the same seesaw on the Moon). Chosen with the tabs above the canvas.
- Your guess: where B balances
-
When omitted Blank
Unit m Default Not set Range 0.1 to 3.9
About this input
Challenge 2 only: where you think the small child must sit to balance, 0.10 to 3.90 m along the plank, set by dragging the dotted seat and locked in. Blank until you guess; the results stay hidden until then.
- Load B mass (required)
-
Unit kg Default 20 Range 0 to 100
About this input
Load B, 0 to 100 kg, picked from shelf B on the canvas. In challenge 3 load B is the mystery box, so this value is not used there.
- Load A position (required)
-
Unit m Default 1 Range 0.1 to 3.9
About this input
Where load A sits along the plank, 0.10 to 3.90 m from its left end. Set by dragging load A on the canvas. In challenge 3 the model seats load A where it balances the mystery box, so the plank starts level.
- Load A mass (required)
-
Unit kg Default 30 Range 0 to 100
About this input
Load A, 0 to 100 kg (0 is an empty seat), picked from shelf A on the canvas: Nothing, Small weight 5, Weight 10, Small child 20, Child 30, Big child 40 or Grown-up 60 kg. Any value from 0 to 100 can be typed in its popover. In challenge 3 load A is a 30 kg child, fixed by the challenge.
Outputs
- Net turning effect (torque)
-
Unit N*m
About this output
The net turning effect (torque) about the pivot, in N m (lbf ft in Imperial units): how much the bigger side wins by. Blank until you guess, and in challenge 3 until you find the box's mass.
- Your guess
-
No unit declared
About this output
How your guess did: right or not this time in Play and challenge 4, a right guess with one sentence on why (which side's turning effect, mass times distance with the plank included, was bigger, or both equal within the pivot's small grip); in challenge 2, spot on (within 5 cm of the balance spot), close (within 12 cm) or not close. Blank until you guess and in challenges 1 and 3.
- Right side turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
The turning effect of everything right of the pivot, in N m (lbf ft). Blank as netTorque.
- The box's mass
-
Unit kg
About this output
Challenge 3: the mystery box's mass, in kg (lb in Imperial units), shown once the seesaw is level and your guess is within 0.6 kg. Blank otherwise.
- Model Status
-
No unit declared
About this output
OK, CHECK (the two loads overlap on the plank; each is still treated as sitting at its own spot and every result still shows) or NOT VALID with the reason (the results are then blank).
- Model version
-
No unit declared
About this output
The version of this model.
- Formula module versions
-
No unit declared
About this output
The formula modules and their versions.
- Time to tip
-
Unit s
About this output
How long the plank takes to tip from level to the ground, in seconds, from its starting speed-up held constant (the true tip is a little slower, at most about 0.5%). Blank when it stays level, until you guess, and in challenge 3 until you find the box's mass.
- Why?
-
No unit declared
About this output
One plain sentence on why it tipped the way it did, or why it stayed level; while a guess is awaited, the prompt to make one. Blank when the inputs are not valid.
- How we got this
-
No unit declared
About this output
How we got this: the working behind the numbers, one step per line, each turning effect as weight times distance with this run's numbers, the two sides, the net, the balance spot for B and how far and how fast it tips, in metric with the Imperial results in brackets in Imperial units. Hidden until you lock in a guess, and in challenge 3 until you find the box's mass.
- Which side went down
-
No unit declared
About this output
Which side went down, in words: Level, or the side named by what sits on it in challenge 3 (the box side, or load A's side), else the left or the right side. Blank until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.
- Stops at
-
Unit deg
About this output
How far the plank tips before its low end touches the ground, in degrees; 0 when it stays level. Blank until you guess.
- The tip, frame by frame: the time and the plank's tilt (positive: the right side down)
-
No unit declared
About this output
The tip frame by frame, 61 rows: the time and the plank's tilt in degrees (positive: the right side down). Only row 0, the plank level at the start, is shown until you guess; while the mystery box is not found the film runs a fixed 1.0 s.
- Which way it went
-
No unit declared
About this output
Which way it went: Left side down, Right side down or Balanced (level). Blank until you lock in a guess.
- Load B turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
Load B's own turning effect about the pivot, its weight times its distance, in N m (lbf ft in Imperial units). Hidden in challenge 3 until you find the box's mass; blank until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.
- Challenge result
-
No unit declared
About this output
No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.
- At your guessed seat: left side turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
Challenge 2: the left side's turning effect with the small child at your guessed seat, in N m (lbf ft in Imperial units). Blank until you lock in your guess and outside challenge 2.
- At your guessed seat: right side turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
Challenge 2: the right side's turning effect with the small child at your guessed seat, in N m (lbf ft in Imperial units). Blank until you lock in your guess and outside challenge 2.
- Challenge goal
-
No unit declared
About this output
The goal of the selected challenge. Blank in Play.
- Balance spot for B
-
Unit m
About this output
Where load B would have to sit, along the plank in m (ft in Imperial units), to balance everything else. Blank when no spot on the plank balances it (the note says why), until you guess, and in challenge 3 until you find the box's mass.
- Balance spot for B: note
-
No unit declared
About this output
Shown instead of the balance spot when there is none on the plank: load B is empty, or no spot on this plank balances it with this load B. Blank otherwise.
- Challenge feedback
-
No unit declared
About this output
What to try next, or why the challenge is met. While a challenge waits for your guess it asks for it. In challenge 3 the plank is level from the start: it gives the method (box mass = load A's mass x its distance / the box's distance) and, once you pick a mass, whether it is too high or too low. Blank in Play.
- Load A distance from the pivot
-
Unit m
About this output
How far load A sits from the pivot, in m (ft in Imperial units). Blank until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.
- Load A turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
Load A's own turning effect about the pivot, its weight times its distance, in N m (lbf ft in Imperial units). Blank until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.
- Load B distance from the pivot
-
Unit m
About this output
How far load B (the mystery box in challenge 3) sits from the pivot, in m (ft in Imperial units). Blank until you guess and when the inputs are not valid.
- Left side turning effect
-
Unit N*m
About this output
The turning effect of everything left of the pivot, in N m (lbf ft): each load's weight times its distance from the pivot, the plank included. Blank as netTorque.
- At your guessed seat: stops at
-
Unit deg
About this output
Challenge 2: how far the plank tips, in degrees, with the small child at your guessed seat (0 when it stays level). Blank until you lock in your guess and outside challenge 2.
- At your guessed seat: which way it tips
-
No unit declared
About this output
Challenge 2: which way the seesaw tips with the small child moved to your guessed seat. Blank until you lock in your guess and outside challenge 2.
- At your guessed seat
-
No unit declared
About this output
Challenge 2: one sentence on what happens with the small child at your guessed seat: which side goes down and the two sides' mass x distance. Blank until you lock in your guess and outside challenge 2.
LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.
Methodology
Purpose and model boundary
Many people think the heavier side of a seesaw always goes down. This lab tests that idea. You put loads on a 4 m plank, slide the pivot (the point the plank rests on and turns about), make your guess about which way it will tip, and then the lab shows what really happens.
For each setup the model works out the turning effect of each side, which way the plank tips, where load B would have to sit to balance, how far the plank tips before its low end touches the ground, and how long that takes. It works on Earth, the Moon or Mars. Four challenges follow, ending with a mystery box whose mass you find by balancing it.
The lab is for learning one idea: what tips a seesaw is weight times distance from the pivot, not weight alone. It is not a model of a real playground seesaw. The loads are points, the plank never bends, and the time to tip is a close estimate rather than an exact one.
The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what the model sends back: the plank's tilt at each moment of the tip, the balance spot in challenge 2 and the box's true mass on its scale in challenge 3. The page works out no turning effect, tilt or balance spot itself.
Inputs and units
| Input | Meaning and unit |
|---|---|
| Pivot position | Where the pivot sits, measured along the plank from its left end: 1.00 to 3.00 m (default 2.00 m). |
| Load A mass | 0 to 100 kg (default 30 kg); 0 is an empty seat. Mass is how much stuff something is made of, in kilograms (kg). The shelf offers Nothing (0), Small weight (5), Weight (10), Small child (20), Child (30), Big child (40) and Grown-up (60 kg); any value from 0 to 100 kg can also be typed. |
| Load A position | Where load A sits along the plank: 0.10 to 3.90 m from the left end (default 1.00 m). |
| Load B mass | 0 to 100 kg (default 20 kg), from the same kind of shelf. In challenge 3 load B is the mystery box, so this value is not used there. |
| Load B position | Where load B sits along the plank: 0.10 to 3.90 m (default 3.60 m). |
| World | Earth, the Moon or Mars (default Earth). |
| Units shown | Metric or Imperial (default Metric). It changes only how some results are shown. |
| Your guess: which way it tips | Play and challenge 4: Not yet predicted (the start), Left side down, Right side down or Balanced. |
| Your guess: where B balances | Challenge 2 only: a spot from 0.10 to 3.90 m along the plank; blank until you guess. |
| Your guess: the box's mass | Challenge 3 only: 0 to 100 kg; blank until you place your guess. |
| Mystery box number | Challenge 3 only: a whole number from 0 to 999 (default 0) that picks the box's hidden mass. |
| Challenge number | 0 for Play, or 1 to 4 for a challenge (default 0). |
Where each input is set:
- On the canvas: every input. There is no input panel. Drag the pivot triangle under the plank; pick each load from its shelf; drag each load along the plank; use the world chips and the units chips; pick a guess with the three buttons and press Lock in my guess. In challenge 2 you drag a dotted seat, and in challenge 3 you drag a dotted needle on the box's scale strip and can press New box. The tabs above the canvas choose Play or a challenge.
- On the canvas, positions move in steps of 0.05 m and masses in steps of 0.5 kg.
Fixed values: the plank is 4.00 m long with a mass of 10 kg spread evenly along it, and its middle line sits 0.50 m above the ground at the pivot. Gravity g is 9.80665 m/s² on Earth (shown as 9.81), 1.62 m/s² on the Moon and 3.73 m/s² on Mars. In Imperial units the turning effects are shown in lbf ft (1 lbf ft = 1.3558179483314 N m), the balance spot in feet (1 ft = 0.3048 m) and the box's mass in pounds (1 lb = 0.45359237 kg). Angles and times do not change.
Governing relationships
Weight. Weight is the pull of gravity on a mass: weight = mass × g, in newtons (N).
Turning effect (torque). A turning effect says how strongly something turns the plank about the pivot. In words, turning effect = weight × distance from the pivot. As an equation, τ = m × g × d, where m is the mass, g is gravity and d is the distance from the pivot to the load, in metres. The unit is the newton metre (N m). A load sitting right on the pivot has d = 0, so it does not turn the plank at all.
The plank's own weight. An even plank acts as if all its weight sits at its middle, 2.00 m along. When the pivot is not under the middle, the longer part of the plank turns it towards that side, with τ = 10 kg × g × (distance from the pivot to the plank's middle).
Each side and the net. The left turning effect adds up everything left of the pivot, plank included, and the right turning effect adds up everything right of it. The net turning effect is how much the bigger side wins by.
Which way it tips. The model adds mass × distance with a sign, counting right of the pivot as positive and left as negative:
M_net = m_A × d_A + m_B × d_B + 10 kg × d_P (in kg m)
Here d_A, d_B and d_P are the signed distances of load A, load B and the plank's middle from the pivot. If the size of M_net is 0.20 kg m or less, the plank stays level: this is the pivot's small grip, a little stickiness that holds a nearly balanced plank still. Otherwise the side with the bigger turning effect goes down.
Why gravity does not change the answer. Every turning effect, on both sides, is multiplied by the same g. Comparing the two sides, g cancels out. The pivot's grip also grows with g, so the verdict is the same on every world. Only the speed of the tip changes.
Balance spot for B. This is where load B would have to sit so that M_net = 0 with everything else kept:
spot for B = pivot position - (m_A × d_A + 10 kg × d_P) ÷ m_B
It is shown only when it lies on the plank (0.10 to 3.90 m). An empty load B (0 kg) cannot balance anything.
How far it tips. The plank turns until its low end touches the ground. With d_end the distance from the pivot to the end that goes down and h = 0.50 m, the stop angle θ follows from sin θ = h ÷ d_end. Because the pivot stays between 1.00 and 3.00 m, the stop angle is between about 9.6° and 30.0°.
How long it takes. The moment of inertia I says how hard it is to start something turning. For point loads and an even plank, I = m_A × d_A² + m_B × d_B² + 10 kg × (L² ÷ 12 + d_P²), with L = 4 m. Newton's second law for rotation, net turning effect = I × α, gives the starting angular speed-up α = g × |M_net| ÷ I (in rad/s²). Holding α steady, the time to reach the stop angle (in radians) is t = √(2 × θ ÷ α).
Calculation sequence
- The model checks your inputs and sets the status.
- In a challenge, the challenge's own values replace the locked inputs. In challenge 3, load B becomes the box at 3.50 m, and the box number picks its mass from a fixed list of 12 masses.
- It finds the signed distance of each load and of the plank's middle from the pivot.
- It works out each turning effect, each side's total and the net.
- It decides the tilt: level within the pivot's grip, or the side with the bigger turning effect goes down.
- It finds the balance spot for load B.
- It finds the stop angle, the moment of inertia, the starting speed-up and the time to tip.
- It builds the film of the tip: 61 moments from level to the stop, with the tilt growing as ½ × α × t² and never passing the stop angle. A level plank stays level for 1 s.
- It compares your guess with what happened, picks a Why? sentence, writes out the working and scores any challenge.
Outputs and interpretation
- Which way it went: left side down, right side down or balanced (level).
- Net turning effect (torque): how much the bigger side wins by, in N m (lbf ft); 0 when level.
- Balance spot for B: where load B would balance everything else, in m along the plank (ft). When there is no such spot on the plank, a short note says why instead.
- Left and right side turning effects: each side's total, in N m (lbf ft).
- Stops at: how far the plank tips before its end touches the ground, in degrees; 0 when it stays level.
- Time to tip: from level to the ground, in seconds; blank when it stays level.
- Your guess: whether your guess was right. In challenge 2 it says whether your seat was spot on (within 5 cm of the balance spot), close (within 12 cm) or not close.
- Why?: one plain sentence on why it tipped that way or stayed level.
- How we got this: the working, one step per line, with this run's numbers.
- The tip, frame by frame: 61 rows of time and tilt in degrees (positive means the right side is down).
On the canvas, the dotted plank is your guess and the solid plank is what really happened. When your guess is right, the solid plank ends inside the dotted one. In challenge 2 a solid seat marks the real balance spot, and in challenge 3 a solid tick on the scale strip marks the box's true mass once you have found it.
Challenges
Each challenge is scored MET or NOT MET, with no points, and gives a hint while it is not met.
- Lift the grown-up. A 60 kg grown-up sits at 0.20 m and a 20 kg small child at 3.80 m, on Earth. Only the pivot moves. There is no guess: the plank responds each time you move the pivot. It is met when the seesaw is level.
- Where must the small child sit? A 40 kg big child sits at 1.25 m, the 20 kg small child at 2.75 m and the pivot at 2.00 m. Drag the dotted seat to where you think the small child would balance, then lock it in. It is met when your guess is within 0.12 m of the balance spot. Nothing is shown until you lock in.
- Mystery box. The box sits at 3.50 m with the pivot at 2.00 m, and its mass is hidden. Choose load A from the shelf (typed masses are not offered here), move it, and pick a world if you like, until the seesaw is level. Then work out the box's mass and lock in your guess. It is met when the seesaw is level and your guess is within 0.6 kg of the box's mass. You can try as many setups as you like: until it is met, the lab shows only which way it tips and the stop angle. The turning effects, the balance spot, the time to tip and the box's mass stay hidden, and the film always lasts 1.0 s so its speed gives nothing away. Moving load A off balance turns it back to NOT MET. New box picks another hidden mass.
- Same seesaw on the Moon. A 60 kg grown-up at 1.50 m and a 20 kg small child at 3.50 m are level on Earth. Guess which way the same seesaw tips on the Moon, then lock it in. It is met when your guess is Balanced. Nothing is shown until you lock in.
The big idea: the heavier side does not always go down. A seesaw tips towards the side with the bigger weight × distance from the pivot, counting the plank's own weight. A light child far out can beat a heavy child close in, and the same setup balances on every world because gravity changes both sides by the same share.
Validation and status logic
The status reads the first match:
- NOT VALID when an input is outside its allowed values, checked in this order: the pivot position, load A's mass, load A's position, load B's mass, load B's position, the world, the units, and then the challenge number, the guesses and the box number.
- CHECK when two loads, both with some mass, sit closer than 0.30 m to each other. Everything is still worked out.
- OK otherwise.
Assumptions and limitations
- The loads are points, each at its own spot on the plank. Two loads closer than 0.30 m would really overlap.
- The plank is 4 m long, rigid, 10 kg and even, and it turns on a fixed pivot with a small grip of 0.20 kg m (times g). Nothing slides or bounces.
- The time to tip holds the starting speed-up steady. As the plank tilts, the real turning effect shrinks a little, so a real plank is slower by up to about 0.5% (at a 30° stop).
- Only Earth, the Moon and Mars are offered. There is no air and no water around the seesaw.
- The 12 mystery-box masses are fixed teaching values. They are hidden on the page, not secret.
Restrictions and non-computing states
When the status is NOT VALID, every result is blank, and a selected challenge reads NOT MET.
Before you lock in a guess in Play and challenge 4, or a seat in challenge 2, every result is held back: the film shows only the level plank at the start, the Why? card asks for your guess and the working stays hidden. In challenge 3, until the challenge is met, only the tilt, the stop angle and a 1.0 s film are shown, as described under Challenges.
Errors and warnings
The model's messages, in the order it checks them (first match wins):
- NOT VALID, pivot off its track: the pivot position is blank or outside 1.00 to 3.00 m.
- NOT VALID, load A's mass: load A is outside 0 to 100 kg.
- NOT VALID, load A off the plank: load A's position is outside 0.10 to 3.90 m.
- NOT VALID, load B's mass: load B is outside 0 to 100 kg.
- NOT VALID, load B off the plank: load B's position is outside 0.10 to 3.90 m.
- NOT VALID, world: the world is not Earth, the Moon or Mars.
- NOT VALID, units: the units are not Metric or Imperial.
- NOT VALID, challenge, guess or box number: the challenge number is not a whole number from 0 to 4, a guess or answer is not one of its allowed values, or the box number is not a whole number from 0 to 999.
- CHECK, the loads overlap: the two loads sit closer than 0.30 m; each is still treated as sitting at its own spot, and every result is shown.
- OK: the inputs are valid and the loads do not overlap.
References
This laboratory is an educational model of a seesaw: a plank resting on a pivot, with two loads on it. Each load turns the plank with a turning effect (torque) equal to its weight times its distance from the pivot, and the plank's own weight acts at its middle. The plank stays level when the turning effects on the two sides match, which is the second condition for equilibrium, and otherwise tips towards the bigger side. How fast it tips comes from Newton's second law for rotation, with the moment of inertia of point loads and an even plank, and constant angular speed-up from rest.
Sources and further reading
- Torque as force times lever arm, the perpendicular distance from the pivot: Georgia State University HyperPhysics, Torque and Equilibrium, Department of Physics and Astronomy. HyperPhysics
- The size of a torque, the lever arm, and adding torques with a sign for each turning direction: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 10.6, Torque. OpenStax
- The conditions for balance, zero net torque, and a body's weight acting at its centre of mass: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 12.1, Conditions for Static Equilibrium. OpenStax
- A worked torque balance: an unknown mass found by balancing a stick on a pivot, with the stick's own weight at its middle and a balance that does not depend on g: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 12.2, Examples of Static Equilibrium, Example 12.3. OpenStax
- The moment of inertia of point masses and of a thin rod about its middle, and the parallel-axis theorem: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 10.5, Calculating Moments of Inertia. OpenStax
- Newton's second law for rotation, net torque equals moment of inertia times angular acceleration: OpenStax, University Physics Volume 1, Rice University, section 10.7, Newton's Second Law for Rotation. OpenStax
No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.
This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; a real seesaw has seats of real size, a plank that bends a little and a pivot with its own friction, so its balance spots and tip times differ slightly.
Links were current at build time. If one moves, search the document's title rather than reporting a broken link as a defect.
Found a problem, or have an idea?
Tell us if a result looks wrong, a label is unclear, or something is missing. We read every message.