Motion & gravity

Orbital Transfer Planner

Plans an orbital transfer between two circular, coplanar orbits around the Earth, Mars or the Sun: the Hohmann or bi-elliptic burns, the total delta-v and the largest burn, the transfer time, the phase angle the target must lead by, the miss at arrival after a chosen wait, the next launch window and the synodic period, both routes compared, 181 animation frames positioned by Kepler's equation (six fixed Newton steps with a rigorous error bound), the conic shapes and the burn table; refuses inputs out of range plainly, and scores five challenges. For learning orbital mechanics and transfer planning.

Last updated

Calculator overview

Inputs and outputs

This summary comes from the calculator's published input and output contract.

Inputs

Parking orbit radius (required)
About this input

r1, the radius of the circular parking orbit the spacecraft starts on, in km from the body's centre, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000; it must lie above the body's surface.

Unit km Default 7000 Range 1000 to 2000000000
Kepler explorer frame (required)
About this input

The transfer frame, 1 to 120, whose six Newton steps the Kepler explorer shows (in bi-elliptic mode frames 61 to 120 are on the second leg).

Default 15 Range 1 to 120
Target lead at the start (required)
About this input

phi0, how far the target leads the spacecraft at time 0, in degrees counter-clockwise, from -180 to 180.

Unit deg Default 60 Range -180 to 180
Transfer type (required)
About this input

Hohmann (two burns and half an ellipse tangent to both orbits) or Bi-elliptic (three burns via the intermediate orbit), chosen from the list.

Default Hohmann Allowed Hohmann, Bi-elliptic
Target orbit radius (required)
About this input

r2, the radius of the circular target orbit, in km, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000; above the surface and at most 99 times r1 (or at least r1/99). A smaller r2 than r1 is an inward transfer.

Unit km Default 26560 Range 1000 to 2000000000
Central body (required)
About this input

The body the orbits circle: Earth, Mars or the Sun, chosen from the list. It sets the gravitational parameter mu and the body's radius, which every orbit must clear.

Default Earth Allowed Earth, Mars, Sun
Your prediction (challenge 1) (required)
About this input

Your prediction in challenge 1: Not yet predicted, First burn or Second burn, chosen from the list. The burn sizes stay hidden until you predict.

Default Not yet predicted Allowed Not yet predicted, First burn, Second burn
Challenge number (required)
About this input

0 for none, or 1 to 5 to load a challenge. A challenge fixes the body, the transfer type, the orbits, the lead and the wait, and leaves only its free input to you.

Default 0 Range 0 to 5
Intermediate orbit radius (required)
About this input

rb, the bi-elliptic turning radius, in km, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000; in bi-elliptic mode it must lie from the larger orbit's radius to 99 times the smaller. Checked in Hohmann mode too, where it sets the route comparison.

Unit km Default 80000 Range 1000 to 2000000000
Departure wait (required)
About this input

w, how long the spacecraft coasts on its parking orbit before the first burn, in parking orbits (one parking orbit is one revolution), from 0 to 100.

Unit parking orbits Default 0.5 Range 0 to 100

Outputs

Orbit shapes: the parking and target circles and the transfer ellipses (centre, semi-axes and rotation; the body is at the origin)
About this output

The conic shapes the view draws: the parking and target circles and the transfer ellipses (the second blank for Hohmann), each by centre (km), semi-major and semi-minor axes (km) and rotation (degrees); the body sits at the origin, one focus of every ellipse.

No unit declared
Animation frames: 181 frames (31 parking, 120 transfer, 30 arrival) with the spacecraft's position and heading, the target's position and their separation
About this output

The animation: one row per frame (181: 31 parking, 120 transfer with 60 per bi-elliptic leg, 30 arrival) with the time (h), the phase, the spacecraft position (km) and unit heading, the target position (km), their separation (km) and, on transfer frames, the Kepler residual (rad).

No unit declared
Next launch window
About this output

The wait from time 0 to the first departure with the required lead, parking orbits; blank when the orbits coincide.

Unit parking orbits
Parking orbit speed
About this output

The circular speed on the parking orbit, km/s.

Unit km/s
Parking orbit period
About this output

The period of the parking orbit, h.

Unit h
Parking orbit radius used
About this output

The parking orbit radius used, km (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

Unit km
Next launch window in hours
About this output

The next launch window in hours from time 0; blank when the orbits coincide.

Unit h
Largest burn
About this output

Which burn is largest in size: First burn, Second burn, Third burn, or Tie when two reach the largest within 1 part in 1E9 (or all are 0).

No unit declared
Explorer eccentric anomaly
About this output

The eccentric anomaly E after six Newton steps for the explorer frame, rad.

Unit rad
Kepler explorer: the six Newton steps for the chosen transfer frame
About this output

The Kepler explorer: one row per Newton step 0 to 6 for the chosen transfer frame, with E (rad), the residual f(E) (rad), the slope f'(E) and the correction -(f/f') (rad).

No unit declared
Formula module versions
About this output

The formula modules embedded in the workbook and their versions.

No unit declared
Model version
About this output

The workbook version.

No unit declared
Model Status
About this output

OK, CHECK (the orbits coincide, or the Kepler error bound exceeds 1E-10 rad) or NOT VALID with the reason. When NOT VALID every model result and grid cell is blank; the challenge result, goal and feedback still show.

No unit declared
Ratio of radii (target to parking)
About this output

r2/r1, the ratio of the target radius to the parking radius.

No unit declared
Transfer time
About this output

The time from the first burn to arrival, h.

Unit h
Transfer time in days
About this output

The transfer time in days.

Unit days
Transfer ellipse eccentricity
About this output

The eccentricity of the (first) transfer ellipse.

No unit declared
Departure wait in hours
About this output

The departure wait in hours.

Unit h
View radius
About this output

The radius the view should fit, km: 1.1 times the largest drawn radius.

Unit km
Transfer type used
About this output

The transfer type used (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

No unit declared
Target orbit speed
About this output

The circular speed on the target orbit, km/s.

Unit km/s
Synodic period
About this output

The time between launch windows (the synodic period), h; blank when the orbits coincide.

Unit h
Synodic period in days
About this output

The synodic period in days; blank when the orbits coincide.

Unit days
Required phase angle
About this output

The lead the target must have at the first burn so it arrives with the spacecraft, degrees in (-180, 180].

Unit deg
Target orbit period
About this output

The period of the target orbit, h.

Unit h
Target orbit radius used
About this output

The target orbit radius used, km (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

Unit km
Target lead at the start used
About this output

The target lead used, degrees (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

Unit deg
Challenge goal
About this output

The goal of the selected challenge; blank with no challenge.

No unit declared
Challenge feedback
About this output

A prompt while challenge 1 awaits a prediction, else the met or not-met feedback of the selected challenge; blank with no challenge.

No unit declared
Central body used
About this output

The central body used (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

No unit declared
Challenge result
About this output

No challenge selected, MET or NOT MET.

No unit declared
Challenge score
About this output

100 when the selected challenge is met, else 0.

No unit declared
Challenge: the value scored
About this output

The value the selected challenge scores: |first burn| - |second burn| (challenge 1, km/s), the miss angle (challenges 2 and 5, degrees), the bi-elliptic saving (challenge 3, km/s) or the total delta-v (challenge 4, km/s); blank with no challenge, while withheld, or when not valid.

No unit declared
Burns: when and where each burn happens, its delta-v and its thrust direction
About this output

One row per burn (the third blank for Hohmann): the burn number, its time (h), its position (km), its delta-v (km/s, withheld while challenge 1 awaits a prediction) and its thrust direction (prograde for a positive burn).

No unit declared
Miss distance at arrival
About this output

The distance between the spacecraft and the target at arrival, km.

Unit km
Miss angle at arrival
About this output

The target's angle minus the spacecraft's at arrival, degrees in (-180, 180]; positive means the target is ahead.

Unit deg
Actual phase angle at departure
About this output

The lead the target actually has at the first burn, after the wait, degrees in (-180, 180].

Unit deg
Bi-elliptic transfer time
About this output

The bi-elliptic transfer time, h; blank when not comparable.

Unit h
Bi-elliptic saving
About this output

The Hohmann total minus the bi-elliptic total, km/s: positive means the bi-elliptic route is cheaper; blank when not comparable.

Unit km/s
Bi-elliptic total delta-v
About this output

The bi-elliptic total delta-v through the intermediate radius, km/s; blank when the intermediate radius is not usable (below the larger orbit or above 99 times the smaller).

Unit km/s
Cheaper route
About this output

Hohmann, Bi-elliptic, or Equal when the totals agree within 1 part in 1E9; blank when not comparable.

No unit declared
Kepler error bound
About this output

A rigorous bound on the error of E: the largest residual divided by (1 - e) for the most eccentric leg, rad.

Unit rad
Explorer eccentricity
About this output

The eccentricity of the explorer frame's leg.

No unit declared
Intermediate orbit radius used
About this output

The intermediate orbit radius used, km (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

Unit km
Explorer mean anomaly
About this output

The canonical mean anomaly M of the explorer frame, rad (from periapsis toward apoapsis, 0 to pi).

Unit rad
Largest Kepler residual
About this output

The largest Kepler residual (E - e sin E) - M over the 120 transfer frames, rad.

Unit rad
Kepler explorer frame used
About this output

The Kepler explorer frame used (never overridden by a challenge).

No unit declared
Hohmann transfer time
About this output

The Hohmann transfer time, h, in either mode.

Unit h
Third burn
About this output

The third burn of a bi-elliptic transfer, km/s, signed; blank for Hohmann and while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.

Unit km/s
Second burn
About this output

The second burn, km/s, signed. Withheld while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.

Unit km/s
First burn
About this output

The first burn, km/s, signed: positive speeds up, negative slows down. Withheld while challenge 1 awaits a prediction.

Unit km/s
Hohmann total delta-v
About this output

The Hohmann total delta-v, km/s, in either mode.

Unit km/s
Departure wait used
About this output

The departure wait used, parking orbits (the challenge's when a challenge fixes it).

Unit parking orbits
Total delta-v
About this output

The sum of the burn magnitudes, km/s.

Unit km/s
This page is provided by LogicCommons for informational purposes only. Results are analysis outputs computed from the inputs you supply and are not professional advice. Verify all inputs and results independently.

LogicCommons is in beta. If a result, label, or reference looks wrong, tell us here; we read every message.

Methodology

Purpose and model boundary

This lab plans a transfer between two circular, coplanar orbits around one central body: the Earth, Mars or the Sun. A spacecraft starts on a parking orbit and a target moves on a target orbit; both move counterclockwise. The spacecraft coasts on the parking orbit for a wait you choose, then flies a Hohmann transfer (two burns and half an ellipse) or a bi-elliptic one (three burns by way of a far intermediate orbit). The model gives the size of each burn, the total delta-v and the largest burn, the transfer time and the transfer ellipse's eccentricity, the phase angle the target must lead by at departure, the lead it actually has, the angle and distance by which the spacecraft misses the target at arrival, the wait to the next launch window and the synodic period. It compares the two routes side by side. It computes 181 animation frames of the whole trip, places the spacecraft on each transfer ellipse with Kepler's equation, and returns the circles and ellipses of the scene and a table of the burns. At Advanced a Kepler explorer shows, for one chosen frame, each of the six Newton steps that solve Kepler's equation. Five scored challenges turn the lab into exercises.

Every quantity except the eccentric anomaly is a closed form. Kepler's equation is solved by exactly six Newton steps from a starting point that is proven to lie on the safe side of the root, so the steps can never diverge, and the model reports a rigorous bound on the error that remains. The key choice is that all geometry and timing is computed in parking orbits (time) and ratios of radii, which do not depend on the body's gravitational parameter μ. μ only converts the results to real time and to speeds. So a circular leg and two coincident orbits come out exactly, with no special case.

It is a lab for learning orbital mechanics, not for planning real missions. It models two-body motion around a point mass, with instantaneous burns along the direction of motion. There is no atmosphere, no other body's gravity, no escape from or capture at a planet, and no change of orbital plane.

The model is the calculation authority. The page sends the values you set to the model and draws only what the model returns: every spacecraft and target position, heading, orbit circle, ellipse, burn position and thrust direction comes from the model's results; the page computes no orbit itself.

Inputs and units

Input Meaning and unit
Central body Earth, Mars or Sun. It sets μ and the body's radius (see Governing relationships).
Transfer type Hohmann or Bi-elliptic.
Parking orbit radius r1, the radius of the parking orbit measured from the body's centre, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000 km.
Target orbit radius r2, the radius of the target orbit, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000 km. It may be smaller than r1: an inward transfer.
Intermediate orbit radius rb, the far radius of the bi-elliptic route, from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000 km. It is checked in Hohmann mode too, where it sets the route compared.
Target lead φ0, how many degrees the target is ahead of the spacecraft at time 0, from −180 to 180.
Departure wait w, how long the spacecraft coasts on the parking orbit before the first burn, from 0 to 100 parking orbits. One parking orbit is one revolution of the parking orbit.
Kepler frame (Advanced) The transfer frame, 1 to 120, whose Newton steps the Kepler explorer shows. In bi-elliptic mode frames 61 to 120 are on the second leg.
Challenge number 0 for free exploration; 1 to 5 loads one of the five challenges.
Your burn prediction (challenge 1) Not yet predicted, First burn or Second burn. Only challenge 1 uses it.

Units: radii and positions in kilometres (km), speeds and delta-v in km/s, angles in degrees (the Kepler quantities in radians), real time in hours and days. The wait is entered in parking orbits because the phasing depends only on time in those units: in low Earth orbit one parking orbit is about 1.5 hours, around the Sun at the Earth's distance it is about a year.

Sign conventions: the body is at the origin. The spacecraft starts at angle 0 on the parking orbit and the target at angle φ0 on the target orbit; angles are measured counterclockwise from +x. A positive burn speeds the spacecraft up (along its motion), a negative one slows it down.

Every input is in the input panel. In a challenge, the inputs the challenge fixes cannot be changed.

Governing relationships

The bodies. The model's data gives each body's gravitational parameter μ and equatorial radius:

Body μ (km³/s²) Equatorial radius (km)
Earth 398,600.4418 6,378.137
Mars 42,828.37 3,396.19
Sun 132,712,440,018 695,700

These are standard design values; the lab claims nothing beyond these digits.

Circular orbits. The periods are P1 = 2π·r1·√(r1/μ) and P2 = 2π·r2·√(r2/μ), reported in hours, and the circular speeds are v1 = √(μ/r1) and v2 = √(μ/r2). The ratio of the periods is ρ = (r1/r2)·√(r1/r2): the target turns 360·ρ degrees during one parking orbit.

The Hohmann transfer. The transfer ellipse touches both circles. Its semi-major axis is aH = (r1 + r2)/2 and its eccentricity eH = |r2 − r1|/(r1 + r2). It takes half the ellipse's period, which is τH = 0.5·(aH/r1)·√(aH/r1) parking orbits. The two burns are

  • Δv1 = √(μ/r1)·(√(2r2/(r1 + r2)) − 1), at departure;
  • Δv2 = √(μ/r2)·(1 − √(2r1/(r1 + r2))), at arrival.

Each is the difference between the circle's speed and the ellipse's speed at that point, from the vis-viva relation v² = μ·(2/r − 1/a). Both burns are positive outward and both negative inward. The Hohmann total is |Δv1| + |Δv2|.

The bi-elliptic transfer. The first ellipse runs from r1 out to rb, with a1 = (r1 + rb)/2 and e1 = |rb − r1|/(rb + r1); the second from rb to r2, with a2 = (r2 + rb)/2 and e2 = |rb − r2|/(rb + r2). Each leg is half an ellipse, so the legs take τ1 = 0.5·(a1/r1)·√(a1/r1) and τ2 = 0.5·(a2/r1)·√(a2/r1) parking orbits. The three burns are

  • Δv1 = √(μ/r1)·(√(2rb/(r1 + rb)) − 1), at departure;
  • Δv2 = √(2μ/rb)·(√(r2/(r2 + rb)) − √(r1/(r1 + rb))), at the intermediate radius;
  • Δv3 = √(μ/r2)·(1 − √(2rb/(r2 + rb))), at arrival.

The bi-elliptic total is |Δv1| + |Δv2| + |Δv3|. The intermediate radius must be at least the larger of r1 and r2, so the first leg always goes out and the second always comes in. With rb equal to the larger radius, one burn is exactly 0 and the route is the Hohmann transfer.

The route used sweeps 180 degrees around the body (Hohmann) or 360 degrees (bi-elliptic), and lasts τ = τH or τ1 + τ2 parking orbits.

Phasing and windows. Time is counted in parking orbits from time 0. The first burn happens at time w, at angle 360·w; arrival is at time w + τ, at angle 360·w plus the sweep. With W(x) an angle wrapped into (−180, 180]:

  • the required phase, the target's lead at the first burn that makes it arrive together with the spacecraft, is W(sweep − 360·ρ·τ);
  • the actual phase, the target's lead at the first burn, is W(φ0 + 360·(ρ − 1)·w);
  • the arrival miss angle, the target's angle minus the spacecraft's at arrival, is W(φ0 + 360·((ρ − 1)·w + ρ·τ) − sweep). Positive means the target is ahead. It equals the actual phase minus the required phase, wrapped.

The target's lead falls by q = 360·(1 − ρ) degrees per parking orbit (it rises for an inward transfer). The next launch window is the first wait from time 0 at which the lead equals the required phase: z/|q| parking orbits, with z the angle still to go, MODP(sign(q)·(φ0 − required phase)), reduced to [0, 360). A lead within 1×10⁻⁹ degree short of the required phase counts as "now", 0. Windows then repeat every synodic period, 1/|1 − ρ| parking orbits. The model reports the window in parking orbits and in hours, and the synodic period in hours and days.

The orbits coincide when |1 − ρ| ≤ 1×10⁻⁹. Then both Hohmann burns are exactly 0, the transfer takes exactly half an orbit, the required phase is exactly 0, the miss equals the lead, and the lead never changes, so the next window and the synodic period are blank.

Kepler's equation: six fixed Newton steps. On an ellipse the spacecraft moves fast near the body and slowly far out, so its position at evenly spaced times needs Kepler's equation, M = E − e·sin E, between the mean anomaly M (proportional to time) and the eccentric anomaly E (the position). For transfer frame j of a leg with N frames (N = 120 for Hohmann, 60 per bi-elliptic leg), the mean anomaly is M = π·mm/120 radians, measured from the ellipse's nearest point toward its farthest, with mm = j·(120/N) on an outward leg. An inward leg starts at the far point; by the time symmetry of the ellipse its position j frames in is the mirror image of the outward position at N − j, so the model solves the mirrored problem and every M is one of the 121 values π·mm/120, mm = 0 to 120, from 0 to π.

  • Start: E0 = min(M/(1 − e), M + e, π).
  • Six steps: E(i+1) = E(i) − (E(i) − e·sin E(i) − M)/(1 − e·cos E(i)), for i = 0 to 5.
  • The residual of each frame is (E6 − e·sin E6) − M.

Why this always converges: f(E) = E − e·sin E − M is strictly increasing (its slope 1 − e·cos E is at least 1 − e ≥ 0.02, because e is at most 0.98) and convex on [0, π]. The start E0 lies at or above the root and not past π. A Newton step on an increasing convex function from a point at or above the root lands at or above the root and not beyond its starting point, so the six iterates fall steadily onto the root and never leave [0, π]. For a circular leg (e = 0) the start is M and every correction is exactly 0.

By the mean value theorem, |E6 − E| ≤ |f(E6)|/(1 − e). The model reports the largest absolute residual over the 120 transfer frames and the Kepler error bound, that residual divided by 1 − e for the most eccentric leg in use, both in radians. Inside the input ranges the bound stays at rounding level, about 2.2×10⁻¹⁴ rad at its worst; a guard reads CHECK if it ever exceeds 1×10⁻¹⁰ rad.

Positions on a transfer leg. With the leg's start radius rs, end radius re, semi-major axis a and eccentricity e, the semi-minor axis is b = √(rs·re). In the ellipse's own frame the spacecraft is at (a·(cos E6 − e), ±b·sin E6), with the sign + on an outward leg and − on an inward one. That point is turned to the leg's direction: a leg starts at angle 360·w (leg 1) or 360·w + 180 (leg 2), and its nearest point lies at that angle (outward) or opposite it (inward). The heading is the unit tangent of the ellipse at that point, turned the same way.

The frames. There are 181 frames, k = 0 to 180, in three phases:

Frames Phase Time Spacecraft
0 to 30 Parking w·k/30 parking orbits on the parking circle at angle 360·t
31 to 150 Transfer (Hohmann) or Transfer leg 1 (31 to 90) and Transfer leg 2 (91 to 150) evenly spaced over each leg on the transfer ellipse, as above
151 to 180 Arrival a quarter of the target orbit's period after arrival, in 30 equal steps on the target circle

The target is always on its circle, at angle φ0 + 360·ρ·t. Each frame gives the time in hours, the phase, the spacecraft's position and unit heading, the target's position, their separation and, on transfer frames, the Kepler residual. On a circle the heading is the counterclockwise tangent. The time step is uniform within each phase and within each bi-elliptic leg, but differs between them. With a wait of 0 the 31 parking frames all show time 0. In the arrival phase both move on the target circle at the same rate, so their separation stays at the arrival miss distance, the separation at frame 150.

The shapes. The scene's circles and ellipses are returned as a centre, two semi-axes and a rotation: the parking circle and the target circle about the origin, and each transfer ellipse with the body at one focus. An ellipse's centre lies |re − rs|/2 from the body, opposite its nearest point, and its rotation is the direction of the nearest point, wrapped. The page draws these shapes from these values; it samples no curve.

The burns. Burn 1 is at time w on the parking circle at angle 360·w. Burn 2 is half a turn later, on the target circle (Hohmann) or at the intermediate radius (bi-elliptic). Burn 3, bi-elliptic only, is a full turn after burn 1, on the target circle. Each burn's thrust direction is the counterclockwise tangent for a positive burn, the opposite for a negative one, and 0 for a zero burn.

The comparison. The two routes are compared whenever rb is usable, at least the larger radius and at most 99 times the smaller, also in Hohmann mode. The saving is the Hohmann total minus the bi-elliptic total. The cheaper route is Bi-elliptic when the saving is more than 1×10⁻⁹ times the Hohmann total, Hohmann when it is less than minus that, and Equal otherwise. The largest burn is the one with the largest size; when two sizes are within 1×10⁻⁹ (relative) of the largest, or every burn is 0, it reads Tie.

The view radius. 1.1 times the largest radius drawn (r1, r2 and, for a bi-elliptic transfer, rb): the radius the scene must fit.

Calculation sequence

The model works through the relationships above in this order:

  1. It checks the entered inputs, items 1 to 4 of the status list under Errors and warnings.
  2. It fixes the values solved: your inputs, or in a challenge the challenge's own orbits with only its free input left to you. The Kepler frame and the burn prediction are never replaced.
  3. It looks up μ and the body's radius, and checks the orbits against the surface, the ratio of radii and the intermediate radius (items 5 to 7). Under NOT VALID every result is blank.
  4. It computes the circular orbits, both transfers, the route used, the phasing, the next window and the synodic period.
  5. It solves Kepler's equation on the 120 transfer frames and computes the residuals and the error bound.
  6. It computes the 181 frames, the shapes, the burn table, the Kepler explorer and the comparison of the two routes.
  7. It sets the status and, in a challenge, scores the challenge.

Outputs and interpretation

  • Status: OK, CHECK or NOT VALID, with the reason (see Validation and status logic and Errors and warnings).
  • The burns: the first, second and third burn (km/s, signed; the third blank for Hohmann), the total delta-v, the sum of their sizes (km/s), and which burn is largest (First burn, Second burn, Third burn or Tie).
  • The transfer: the transfer time (hours and days) and the eccentricity of the first transfer ellipse.
  • Phasing: the required and the actual phase (degrees), the arrival miss angle (degrees) and the miss distance at arrival (km).
  • Windows: the wait from time 0 to the next launch window (parking orbits and hours) and the synodic period (hours and days), blank when the orbits coincide.
  • The two routes: the Hohmann total (km/s) and time (h), the bi-elliptic total (km/s) and time (h), the saving (km/s, positive when the bi-elliptic route is cheaper) and the cheaper route (Hohmann, Bi-elliptic or Equal). The bi-elliptic values, the saving and the cheaper route are blank when the intermediate radius is not usable.
  • The orbits: the ratio of radii r2/r1 and the wait in hours.
  • Periods and speeds (Advanced): the parking and target periods (h) and circular speeds (km/s).
  • The Kepler explorer (Advanced): for the chosen frame, its mean anomaly (rad), its leg's eccentricity and the eccentric anomaly after six steps (rad); the largest residual over the transfer frames and the error bound (rad).
  • View radius (Advanced): the radius the scene must fit (km).
  • Values solved (Advanced): the body, transfer type, three radii, lead, wait and Kepler frame actually solved. In a challenge these are the challenge's givens; the Kepler frame stays yours.
  • Versions (Advanced): the model version and the formula module versions.
  • Grids:
    • Orbit frames: 181 rows of time (h), phase, the spacecraft's x and y (km) and heading x and y, the target's x and y (km), the separation (km) and the Kepler residual (rad, transfer frames only; Advanced).
    • Orbit shapes: four rows, the parking orbit, the target orbit and transfer ellipses 1 and 2 (ellipse 2 blank for Hohmann), each with centre x and y, semi-major and semi-minor axis (km) and rotation (degrees).
    • Burn table: three rows, one per burn (the third blank for Hohmann), of the time (h), position (km), delta-v (km/s) and thrust direction.
    • Kepler rows (Advanced): seven rows, steps 0 to 6, of E (rad), f(E) (rad), the slope f′(E) and the correction −f/f′ (rad). Row 6's correction is the step a seventh iteration would take.

Reading the results:

  • From a low orbit of 6,678 km to the geostationary radius of 42,164 km, the Hohmann transfer needs about 2.426 km/s and then 1.467 km/s, about 3.893 km/s in all, in about 5.275 hours, and the target must lead by about 100.66 degrees. The first burn is larger: the low orbit is fast and the far end of the ellipse is slow.
  • An inward transfer mirrors an outward one: the same total and time, both burns negative, the larger burn last.
  • The bi-elliptic route never wins below a ratio of radii of about 11.94, wins only beyond a break-even intermediate radius between about 11.94 and 15.58, and wins for any intermediate radius beyond r2 above about 15.58. It always takes far longer. Inside this lab's cap a win needs a ratio of about 12.45 or more.
  • A miss angle near 0 means the target arrives with the spacecraft. Waiting until the next window fixes a miss; the windows then repeat every synodic period.
  • Near the nearest point of a very eccentric ellipse the spacecraft moves far between frames. The positions are exact at the frame times, and the drawn ellipse shows the path between them.

Challenges

Choose a challenge number from 1 to 5. The model loads that challenge's orbits, and the inputs it fixes replace yours (the "solved" outputs show the values in effect). Only the input the challenge leaves free stays yours. The challenge result reads MET or NOT MET, the score is 100 when met and 0 otherwise, the measured value says how close you are, and a goal and a feedback line say what is asked and what to try next. The status checks still apply inside a challenge.

  1. Which burn is bigger? Predict which burn of a low-orbit-to-geostationary Hohmann transfer is larger. Until you choose a prediction, the burn sizes, the total, the largest burn, the two route totals, the saving, the cheaper route and the burn table's delta-v column stay blank; the scene still plays. The measured value is the first burn's size minus the second's. It is met when your prediction names the largest burn.
  2. Catch the target. Set the departure wait so the spacecraft arrives within 2 degrees of the target. Any window counts.
  3. Beat Hohmann. Choose an intermediate radius so the bi-elliptic route needs less delta-v than the Hohmann transfer. The measured value is the saving.
  4. Delta-v budget. Choose the target orbit so that a total of at most 3.0 km/s reaches a radius of at least 18,000 km.
  5. Mars at the first window. Around the Sun, from 149,600,000 km to 227,940,000 km, set the departure wait so the spacecraft meets Mars within 2 degrees, in the first launch window: the wait must be at most the next window plus half a synodic period.

Validation and status logic

The status reads the first message in the list under Errors and warnings that applies. Items 1 to 4 check the values you entered; items 5 to 9 check the values solved, which are a challenge's own when one is selected. A CHECK still returns every result it can; it marks something that deserves a second look. An inward transfer, a cheaper Hohmann route or a large miss is not a CHECK: each is a normal result.

Assumptions and limitations

  • Two-body motion around a point mass. Circular, coplanar parking and target orbits, both counterclockwise. Burns are instantaneous and along the direction of motion. No atmosphere, no other bodies, no escape or capture, no plane change. The Sun case gives heliocentric burns only, and its Earth and Mars orbits are rounded idealisations.
  • The larger orbit is at most 99 times the smaller, so every transfer ellipse has an eccentricity of at most 0.98. The bi-elliptic intermediate radius runs from the larger radius to 99 times the smaller.
  • 181 frames: 31 parking frames (including time 0 and the first burn), 120 transfer frames (60 per bi-elliptic leg) and 30 arrival frames over a quarter of the target orbit. The time step is uniform within a phase or leg, not between them.
  • Kepler's equation is solved by six Newton steps; the error bound is rigorous to within the rounding of the residual.
  • The body constants are fixed design values.
  • A value within about 1×10⁻⁹ (relative) of a threshold may fall either side of it. This applies to the cheaper-route band, the largest-burn tie, the coincidence band, the next-window rule, the Kepler guard, each challenge limit and the cut at ±180 degrees of a wrapped angle.

Restrictions and non-computing states

Every input is required; a blank or out-of-range value reads NOT VALID. The central body, the transfer type and the burn prediction must each be exactly one of their listed choices.

Under NOT VALID every result and every grid entry is blank. The model and module versions still show, the challenge score reads 0, and a selected challenge reads NOT MET with its goal and its not-met text. A challenge number that is not a whole number from 0 to 5 counts as no challenge selected.

When the orbits coincide, the next window and the synodic period are blank. When the intermediate radius is not usable, the bi-elliptic comparison is blank.

Errors and warnings

The status messages, in the order they are checked:

  1. NOT VALID: the central body and the transfer type must each be one of the listed choices
  2. NOT VALID: every orbit radius (parking, target and intermediate) must be from 1,000 to 2,000,000,000 km
  3. NOT VALID: the target's lead must be from -180 to 180 degrees, the departure wait from 0 to 100 parking orbits and the Kepler frame a whole number from 1 to 120
  4. NOT VALID: the challenge number must be a whole number from 0 to 5 and the burn prediction one of the listed choices
  5. NOT VALID: the parking and target orbits must lie above the surface of the central body: a radius is at or below the body's equatorial radius.
  6. NOT VALID: the larger orbit may be at most 99 times the smaller, so every transfer ellipse keeps an eccentricity of at most 0.98
  7. NOT VALID: for a bi-elliptic transfer the intermediate radius must be at least the larger orbit's radius and at most 99 times the smaller
  8. CHECK: the Kepler error bound exceeds 1×10⁻¹⁰ rad on some transfer frame, so the positions on the transfer may be inaccurate: a guard that cannot fire inside the input ranges.
  9. CHECK: the parking and target orbits coincide (their periods agree to within 1 part in 1×10⁹), so no burn is needed, the target keeps its lead and there is no next window
  10. OK

References

This laboratory is an educational model of an orbital transfer between two circular, coplanar orbits around one central body, with two-body motion and instantaneous burns. The burns of the Hohmann and bi-elliptic transfers are the differences between circular and elliptical speeds given by the vis-viva relation, and the transfer times are half-periods from Kepler's third law. The phase angle, the next launch window and the synodic period follow in closed form from the ratio of the two periods. Positions on each transfer ellipse at evenly spaced times come from Kepler's equation, solved by Newton's method from a starting point that guarantees monotone convergence.

Sources and further reading

  • Kepler's third law, the energy of an orbit and the Hohmann transfer between two circular orbits: S. J. Ling, J. Sanny and W. Moebs, University Physics Volume 1, OpenStax, 2016, section 13.5, Kepler's Laws of Planetary Motion. OpenStax
  • The transfer between two circular orbits by two tangent burns, as first published: W. Hohmann, Die Erreichbarkeit der Himmelskörper, R. Oldenbourg, Munich, 1925.
  • Kepler's equation and its solution by Newton's method, and orbital manoeuvres: the Hohmann and bi-elliptic transfers, phasing and the synodic period: H. D. Curtis, Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students, 4th edition, Butterworth-Heinemann, 2020, chapter 3, Orbital Position as a Function of Time, and chapter 6, Orbital Maneuvers.
  • Two-body orbits, Kepler's equation and orbital transfers: R. R. Bate, D. D. Mueller and J. E. White, Fundamentals of Astrodynamics, Dover Publications, 1971.
  • Orbital manoeuvres, including the comparison of the Hohmann and bi-elliptic transfers: D. A. Vallado, Fundamentals of Astrodynamics and Applications, 4th edition, Microcosm Press, 2013.
  • Physical data of the Earth, Mars and the Sun, which agree with the lab's constants to the digits published there: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Planetary Fact Sheets. NASA

No table or text from any of these publications is reproduced, and none of their authors or publishers has reviewed or endorses this laboratory.

This laboratory is for learning. Its results hold only within its stated ranges; it is not a tool for planning or checking real spacecraft missions.

Results are informational and not professional advice. See our Terms of Use. Powered by SpreadsheetWeb · About · Privacy · Terms